BCN 2013 report on the state of implementation and impact of actions by the ABITS Agency in its comprehensive approach to prostitution and human trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation 2013 Report State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     2       Contents   1.  Introduction  .......................................................................................................................................  3   2.  The  Socio-­‐Educational  Assistance  Service  (SAS)  ..................................................................................  4   2.1.  Description  of  the  service  .....................................................................................................................  4   2.2.  Figures  on  assistance  provided  in  the  public  way  ................................................................................  6   2.3.  Main  user  requests  ...............................................................................................................................  7   2.4.  Assistance  at  the  office  and  individual  work  plans  ...............................................................................  7   2.5.  Sociodemographic  profile  (SAS)  ...........................................................................................................  9   2.6.  Accompaniment  to  resources  and  interventions  ...............................................................................  11   2.7.  Networking  .........................................................................................................................................  14   3.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  (bars,  clubs  and  apartments)  ........  15   3.1.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in  the  Eixample  district  ...............  15   3.2.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in  Les  Corts  district  .....................  18   3.3.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in  the  other  districts  of  the  city.  .  20   4.  Other  social  assistance  services  ........................................................................................................  22   4.1.  Intervention  and  assistance  for  women  in  situations  of  intermediate  emergency  and  social   inclusion  ..............................................................................................................................................  22   4.2.  “Socio-­‐sanitary  pills”  for  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  the  public  way  .....................................  24   5.  Services  and  training  resources  for  training  and  integration  into  employment  ..................................  25   5.1.  DIR  Comprehensive  programme  for  the  re-­‐employment  of  women  engaged  in  prostitution  ...........  25   5.2.  ITI  Personal  advisory  itinerary  for  the  employment  of  women  who  have  been  engaged  in   prostitution  .........................................................................................................................................  33   5.3.  ACCIÓ  Programme  of  comprehensive  intervention  for  transsexual  people  linked  to  prostitution   milieus  in  the  city  of  Barcelona  ...........................................................................................................  36   5.4.  Training,  employment  and  social  integration  programme  with  training  and  employment  itineraries          ............................................................................................................................................................  39   5.5.  The  “Dona  Impuls”  Social  and  Employment  Integration  Programme  ................................................  42   5.6.  Special  accompaniment  mechanism  for  the  integration  into  the  employment  market  and  the  social   fabric   of   women   engaged   in   prostitution   who   seek   employment   alternatives                                                                                                 44   5.7.  Enfilant  l’Agulla  (“Threading  the  Needle”)  innovation  programme  ...................................................  46   5.8.  Rosas  Crafts  Programme  of  Training  in  Sewing  ..................................................................................  47   6.  Services  aimed  at  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  ......................  48   6.1.  Approach  by  the  Socio-­‐Educational  Assistance  Service  to  cases  of  women  victims  of  human   trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation.  .............................................................................  48   6.2  Comprehensive  assistance  for  women  involved  in  prostitution  and  women  who  are  victims  of   human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation    .................................................................  50   6.3.  RAI  Intervention  for  the  recovery,  empowerment  and  integration  into  employment  of  women   who  have  been  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  ........................  53   6.4.  Other  resources  for  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  .................  58   7.  Networking  and  cooperation  ............................................................................................................  59   7.1.  ABITS  Plan  Technical  Committee  ........................................................................................................  59   7.2.  Other  areas  of  action  ..........................................................................................................................  59   7.3.  Knowledge  acquired  through  networking.  Considerations  on  the  sociodemographic  profile  of   women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  the  city  of  Barcelona  ...................................................................  61   8.  Economic  distribution  .......................................................................................................................  63   9.  Impact  indicators  for  programmes  of  integration    into  employment  .................................................  65   10.  Indicators  of  programmes  to  enter  enclosed  spaces  ........................................................................  67   11.  Evaluation  and  conclusions  .............................................................................................................  68       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     3         1.  Introduction       In  2006,  the  Barcelona  City  Council  Plenary  Council  approved  the  ABITS  Plan.  In  order  to  implement  this   plan,   the   agency   of   the   same   name  was   established   in   accordance   with   the  municipal   ordinance   on   measures  to  promote  and  guarantee  co-­‐existence  amongst  citizens   in  the  public  space.  This  ordinance   had  entered  into  effect  just  a  few  months  previously.     On   28  October   2011,   the   governing   team   presented   a   government  measure   aimed   at   improving   and   relaunching  the  ABITS  Agency.  This  decision  was  taken  in  view  of  the  importance  that  the  ABITS  Plan  has   acquired  during  the  current  mandate  and  the  existence  of  the  political  will  to  provide  a  response  to  the   phenomenon   of   prostitution   in   the   city   of   Barcelona   and   to   give   assistance   to   people   who   are   in   a   situation  of  vulnerability,  taking  a  comprehensive,  global  and  coordinated  approach  within  the  powers   available  to  Barcelona  City  Council.   The   measure   served   to   establish   the   three   principles   on   which   all   government   action     regarding     prostitution  are  based:     1. Combating  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation.1   2. Penalising  demand  for  paid  sexual  relations.   3. Providing  assistance  to  people  that  have  been  drawn   into  prostitution  and  are   in  situations  of   vulnerability.     In  order   to  pursue   these  goals,   the  measure  provides   for  a   series  of  actions   in   the   field  of  assistance,   municipal  coordination  and  coordination  with  other  public  authorities  and   institutions.  To  achieve  the   new   objectives   established   and   to   ensure   the   effective   implementation   of   the   actions   planned,   the   ABITS  Agency’s  budget  was  increased  by  67%  in  2012.  This  increase  was  maintained  in  the  2014  budget,   despite  the  current  context  of  spending  restraints.   This  report   includes  figures  on  the  various  programmes  that  the  ABITS  Agency  has   implemented  up  to   the  31st  of  December  2013.  The   report   therefore  presents  a   series  of   closed  annual  data   that  enable   comparisons  to  be  made  with  previous  years.  The  final  section  contains  conclusions  and  evaluations  of   the  actions  carried  out  to  the  present  date.                                                                                                                     1  See  page  50   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     4       2.  The  Socio-­‐Educational  Assistance  Service  (SAS)       2.1.  Description  of  the  service     On  the  1st    of  January  2013,  the  name  of  the  Street  Assistance  and  Mediation  Service  (SAMC),  managed   by  the  ABITS  Agency,  was  changed  to  that  of  the  Socio-­‐Educational  Assistance  Service2  (Servei  d’Atenció   Socioeducativa,  SAS).  The  SAS  provides  a  specific  service  for  people  engaged  in  prostitution  and  victims   of   human   trafficking   for   the  purpose   of   sexual   exploitation,   especially   those  who  offer   and   negotiate   such   services   in   the   street.   The   access   to   SAS   may   be   direct   (women   contacted   in   the   street,   by   telephone  or  without  advance  appointment)  or  through  referral.     SAS   became   operational   in   2006   (the   same   year   which     the   ABITS   Agency   was   established),   with   an   initial   team  of   two   educators   that   has   gradually   been   expanded   since.   This   is   now   a  multidisciplinary   service  provided  by  a  team  of  workers  from  different  specialist  fields:  a  director  (38.5  hours  per  week),   four  educators  (154  hours  per  week),  a  social  worker  (38.5  hours  per  week),  a  psychologist  (38.5  hours   per  week)  and  two  health  workers  (45  hours  per  week).   In  2013,  then,  the  service  was  staffed  by  nine   people  working  a   total  of  314.5  hours  per  week,  an   increase  of  51  hours  per  week  compared  to  2012   (263.5  hours  per  week).   The  educators  and  one  of   the  health  workers   speak  English,  whilst   the  other   health  worker  speaks  Romanian.     A   feature   of   the   new   contract   is   the   provision   of   a   prepaid   bundle   of   200   hours   per   year   for   social   educators,  who  are  available  24  hours  a  day,  365  days  a  year  to  provide  assistance  to  women  during  the   enactment  of  police  operations  aimed  at  people  engaged   in  prostitution,  whatever  the  motive  behind   these  operations  (municipal  ordinance  on  civic  behaviour,  immigration,  dismantling  networks  of  human   trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation...).     The  service,  which  has  offices  at  344,  Carrer  València,  mezzanine,  provides  users  with  a  free  telephone   helpline,  900  722  200,  which  the  educators  themselves  answer,  from  Monday  to  Friday,  from  9  am  to  7   pm.  Moreover,  users  can  attend  the  centre  without  prior  appointment  on  Thursdays,  from  11  am  to  3   pm,   though   most   phone   in   advance   and     arrange   an   appointmentOutreach   services   in   the   public  way     The  areas  of  the  city  covered  by  the  four  educators  and  the  two  health  workers  ,  who  workin  pairs  both   in   the   day   time   and   night   time,   proactively   contacting     the   women   ,   are:   Ciutat   Vella,   Sant   Martí/Eixample,   Les   Corts   and   Zona   Franca.   These  workers   are   present   in   the   street   for   a   total   of   50   hours  per  week,  an  increase  of  10  hours  compared  to  2012.                                                                                                                   2   The   organisation   that   provides   this   service   is   the   Associació   Benestar   i   Desenvolupament   (Welfare   and   Development   Association,  ABD),  which  won  the  public  competition  in  2013  and  was  assigned  a  budget  of  317.867.27  euros  in  both  2013  and   2014.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     5       The  table  below  shows  how  the  intervention  of  the  educators  and  the  health  workers  in  the  street  is   organised:           Direct  assistance  and  mediation,  2013   Ciutat  Vella   Monday  to  Friday   3  hours  between  12  noon  and  7  pm   Tuesday  and  Thursday   10  pm  to  2  am   Ciutat  Vella  +   Sant  Martí/Eixample   Friday   10  pm  to  3  am   Sant  Martí/Eixample   Wednesday   10  pm  to  1  am   Les  Corts     Monday  and  Friday   10  pm  to  2  am  (two  hours  later  in  summer)   Zona  Franca     One  day  per  fortnight     2  hours  between  12  noon  and  7  pm       At   night,   SAS   services   were   increased   by   one   hour   in   2013   compared   to   the   previous   year.   This   additional  time  is  divided  between  Ciutat  Vella  and  Sant  Martí/Eixample  districts.     Since  May   2012,   when   the   Zona   Franca   neighbourhood   (Sants-­‐Montjuïc   district)   was   included   in   the   service,   all   areas   of   the   city  where   prostitution   takes   place   in   the   public   space  had     been   covered.   A   lower   frequency  of   service  was  established   for  Zona  Franca   than   in  other  areas  of   the  city  due   to   the   considerably   lower  number  of  women  and   to   the   level  of  needs  detected.  Nonetheless,   the   service   is   flexible  enough  to  provide  an  effective  response,  always  in  coordination  with  the  Public  Health  Agency,   which  operates  a  mobile  unit  to  provide  assistance  to  drug  users.       From  Monday  to  Friday,  SAS  educators  and  health  workers  are  on  duty   in  the  street,  approaching  the   women  and  informing  them  about  the  service  and  resources  provided  by  the  ABITS  Agency  (in  the  case   of  women  who   have   not   been   contacted   previously)   and   enquiring   about   their   circumstances.   These   workers   also   offer   prophylactic   material   (condoms   and   lubricants)   supplied   by   the   Government   of   Catalonia’s  Health  Ministry  and  the  Office  of  Woman’s  Affair  Directorate.  Provisions  are  also  made  for   occasional  visits  to  the  street  by  the  psychologist  or  the  social  worker  in  order  to  detect  needs  or  at  the   request  of  the  educators.         State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     6       2.2.  Figures  on  assistance  provided  in  the  public  way     In   2013,   the   number   of   contacts   (approaches   by   a  member   of   the   team   to   a  woman   offering   sexual   services  in  the  public  space)  increased  by  25.24%  compared  to  2012.  The  number  of  cases  of  assistance   (recorded   as   “active   listening”   when,   after   an   approach,   a   dialogue   is   established   that   may   include   requests   for   assistance   but   also   the   search   for   support   and   containment,   or   as   “educational   intervention”   when   the   educator   advises,   recommends   or   proposes   different   courses   of   action)   also   increased,  in  this  case  by  10.20%.         The  table  below  details  assistance  provided  in  the  public  space:     ASSISTANCE   PROVIDED   IN  THE   PUBLIC   space   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   %   increase   2012-­‐ 2013       Contacts     1,920   6,880   10,439   13,113   15,417   18,603   20,721   25,950   25.24%   Cases  of   assistance   440   4,216   8,391   9,979   18,771   23,833   26,660   29,739   10.20%   Active   listening   358   2,712   5,122   6,817   13,159   17,627   19,068   21,230   11.33%   Educational   intervention   82   1,504   3,269   3,162   5,612   6,206   7,592   8,149   7.33%                                 The   figures   presented   refer   to   the   number   of   interventions,   not   to   the   number   of   different   women   assisted,  sincethe  team  goes  out  every  day,  and  the  same  woman  may  have  been  contacted  many  times   over  the  course  of  the  year.         State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     7       2.3.  Main  user  requests     Regarding   the   requests   for   assistance   put   forward   by   women   users   of   the   SAS3,   these   increased   by   22.64%  compared  to  2012,  rising  from  9,069  to  11,122.  Such  requests  are  related,  in  the  main,  to  health   care   (2.516),  concerns  about  employment  and  training   (2,075),   legal  assistance   (1,437),  child  care  and   education   (931),   basic   needs   (614)   and   housing   (405).   Compared   to   2012,   there   were   significant   increases   in   requests   related   to   housing   (110.94%),   the   processing   of   documents   (73.02%)   and   child-­‐ related  issues  (62.48%).     Requests   for   legal   assistance  mainly   concerned   immigration,   employment   and   family   law,   court   cases   and  administrative  topics,  such  as  those  related  to  the  municipal  ordinance  on  civic  behaviour.       2.4.  Assistance  at  the  office  and  individual  work  plans     An   individual  file   is  created  for  each  woman  at  the  time  intervention  begins.  To  this  end,  data  already   available  to  the  team  is  used  and  a  work  plan  is  designed.  Some  90%  of  files  opened  are  on  users  that   the  educators  and  health  workers   contact   in   the   street.  However,   the   service  also  assists  any  women   who  are  engaged   in  prostitution   in   the  city,  even   if   they  do  not  offer   their   services   in   the  public  way.   Such  users  account  for  the  remaining  10%.     From  the  beginning  of  its  activity  in  2006  up  to  31  December  2013,  the  SAS  opened  a  total  of  1,195  files,   indicating  that  the  service  has  assisted  1,195  different  women  over  the  aforementioned  period.                                                                                                                   3  Requests  were  made  to  street  educators,  by  telephone  or  at  the  SAS  service  office.   REQUESTS   20114   2012   2012   2013   2013   %   increase   2012-­‐2013   Number  of  requests   4,376   9,069     11,122     22.64%   Main  requests  in  %   %     %     %   %   change   2012-­‐2013   Health  care   30%   2,196   24,21%   2,516   22.63%   14.58%   Training  and  integration  into   employment   25%   1,676   18,48%   2,075   18.67%   21.81%   Legal  assistance   9%   1,329   14,65%   1,437   12.92%   8.13%   Children     573   6,32%   931   8.38%   62.48%   Health  card  processing   9%   748   8,25%   822   7.39%   9.90%   Document  processing     378   4,17%   654   8.80%     73.02%   Social  services     387   4,27%   619   5.58%   59.95%   Basic  needs     710   7,83%   614   5.52%   -­‐13.53%   Psychological   assistance/containment     496   5,47%   448   4.04%   -­‐9.68%   Housing     192   2,12%   405   3.65%   110.94%   Civil  registration     267   2,94%   311   2.80%   16.48%   Others   27%   117   1,29%   290   2.62%   147.87%   TOTAL   100%   9,069   100%   11,122   100%   22.64%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     8       Of  this   total,  126  files  are  new  and  were  opened   in  2013.  Over  the  course  of   the  year,   the  number  of   new  women  provided  with  assistance  reached  409,  an  increase  of  3.28%.  At  December  31,  the  service   was   working   on   a   total   of   333   cases   (active   files).   It   should   be   noted   that   an   inactive   file   can   be   reopened  immediately  through  any  request  put  forward  by  the  user.  In  2013,  32  cases  were  reopened   (compared  to  62  in  2012).           Data  on  files  are  broken  down  as  follows:       2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   New  cases   220   148   179   180   125   111   108   126   Cases  closed   79   94   163   152   125   183   162   169   Cases  reopened   -­‐   -­‐   39   32   16   48   62   32   Number  of   different  women   provided  with   assistance   -­‐   -­‐   -­‐   406   449   441   396   409     Cases  may  be  closed  due  to  the  following  reasons:   -­‐  The  achievement  of  the  goals  established  in  the  work  plan  (response  to  the  request  for  health   care,   coverage   of   basic   needs,   delivery   of   training   and/or   integration   into   employment   activities,  etc.).   -­‐   The  woman’s  prolonged  absence   from  the   service,  which  may  be  caused  by  any  of  various   different   reasons:   return   to   country   of   origin,   changes   in   social   or   family   circumstances,   ceasing  to  engage  in  prostitution  and  other  justified  causes.   -­‐   Referral   to   another   specialist   service   covering   their   needs   and   requests   (SSB   basic   social   services,  CAS  social  assistance  centres,  etc.).                                                                                                                     26  The  total  number  of  women  assisted  since  the  plan  was  launched  in  2006  are  considered  open  files.   37  Cases  in  which  action  concerning  the  women  has  been  taken  in  the  last  six  months  are  considered  active  files.   FILES  ON  WOMEN   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   Files  opened  in  20066   368   546   725   850   960   1,069   1,195   Active  files7   274   307   372   386   363   371   333   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     9       2.5.  Sociodemographic  profile  (SAS)     As  regards  the  profile  of  users  of  the  service,  the  main  groups  are  formed  by  migrant  women   (87%),   mainly   from   Nigeria   (27.6%)   and   Romania   (23.4%)   and,   in   third   place,   local   women   (12.9%).       ORIGIN  %   2007    (b)   2008     (c)   2009     (d)   2010     (e)   2011    (f)   2012   (g)   2013   (h)8   Eastern  Europe    Romania   -­‐   45.2   -­‐   37.4   37.0   -­‐   34.0   38.0   31.0   (26.0)   29.73   (23.42)   Latin  America    Ecuador   17.5   21.7   22.9   26.0   24.0   26.5   (9.16)   24.33   (7.50)   Sub-­‐Saharan   Africa    Nigeria     -­‐     -­‐   -­‐     -­‐   15.3     -­‐   21.0   19.0   21.8     (18.8)   30.03     (27.6)   Spain   21.1   19.8   17.4   15.0   13.0   14.5   12.9   North  Africa      Morocco   6.9   -­‐   7.1   -­‐   4.8   -­‐   3.0   3.0   2.7   (2.15)   2.10   (1.50)   Others   Asia     -­‐   14.0   0.8   1.0   3.0   3.5   (2.9)   0.91   (0.60)   Unknown     0.0   1.6   0.0   0.0   0.0   0.0   TOTAL     100%   100%   100%   100%   100%   100%   100%     Regarding  gender,  data  were  gathered   in  order   to  provide   further   information   for   studying   cases  and   matching   resources   to  needs.   In  2013,  eight  new  transsexual  people   received  assistance,   representing   6.3%   of   the   total   number   of   new   users   of   the   service.   This   enables   us   to   conclude   that,   taking   into   account  the  figures  in  the  historic  records  of  the  SAS,  a  total  of  5.5%  of  all  users  assisted  since  2006  and   whose  SAS  files  are  still  open  are  transsexual  people  (66  women).   El  2013,  approximately  half  of  the  women  assisted  were  mothers  with  children  in  their  care.       LEGAL  STATUS   %   2006   (a)   2007   (b)   2008   (c)   2009   (d)   2010   (e)   2011   (f)   2012   (g)   2013   (h)   Regular   40.3   41.6   45.2   72   76.6   75.7   75.2   72.6   Irregular   60.1   57.6   54   20.7   22.2   23.4   23.7   26.4   Unknown   0.4   0.7   0.6   7.2   1.0   0.8   1.08   1     As  the  previous  table  shows,  most  women  assisted  by  the  SAS  have  a  regular  administrative  status,  and   irregular  situations  account  for  only  26.4%  of  cases.                                                                                                                 8  In  this  table  and  those  that  follow,  the  letter  in  brackets  that  accompanies  the  year  refers  to  the  percentage  number  of  active   files:  (a)  over  a  total  of  218  active  files;  (b)  over  a  total  of  274  active  files;  (c)  over  a  total  of  307  active  files;  (d)  over  a  total  of   372  active  files;  (e)  over  a  total  of  386  active  files;  (f)  over  a  total  of  363  active  files;  (g)  over  a  total  of  371  active  files;  (h)  over  a   total  of  333  active  files.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     10       However,   the  situation  of  Romanian  women,  who  resided   legally   in  Spain  but  were  unable   to  work   in   the   formal   employment   market   in   2013,   prevented   them   from   obtaining   access   to   training   and   integration  into  employment  processes,  despite  the  availability  of  resources  and  the  requests  that  these   users  made.     HEALTH   CARD   %   2006   (a)   2007   (b)   2008   (c)   2009   (d)   2010   (e)   2011   (f)   2012   (g)   2013   (h)   Yes   57.8   72.2   78.5   68.8   83.6   85.9   90   92   No   40.3   28.8   19.2   18.8   15.0   12.9   8.2   7   NS   1.8   0.7   2.2   12.3   2.8   0.5   1.8   1     Ensuring   that   users   have   a   health   card   and   know   how   to   access   health   services   has   always   been   a   priority   of   the   SAS.   In   the   first   quarter   of   2013,   the   team   prioritised   the   provision   of   information   on   Catalan  Government’s  application  of  the  state  decree  on  this  subject,  and  on  ways  in  which  circuits  were   adapted  to  finally  permit  the  continuing  provision  of  healthcare  to  women  that  need  these  services.  At   the  end  of  2013  there  was  a  slight  increase  in  the  percentage  of  women  in  possession  of  the  health  card.   Generally  speaking,   if   they  do  not  have   it,   this   is  because  certain  documents  are  still   to  be  processed,   because   they   have   health   cards   issued   by   other   autonomous   communities,   because   they   have   newly   arrived  here  or  because  they  are  European  Community  citizens  with  private  insurance.     CIVIL   REGISTRATION   %   2006   (a)   2007   (b)   2008   (c)   2009   (d)   2010   (e)   2011   (f)   2012     (g)   2013   (h)   Yes   61.0   60.5   60.2   53.2   73.5   71.6   76.5   79.3   No   38.0   38.6   38.1   32.5   24.1   27.8   21.8   19.5   UNKNOWN   1.8   0.7   1.6   14.2   2.0   0.5   1.6   1.2     With   regard,   precisely,   to   procedures   required   for   access   to   healthcare,   efforts   have   been   made   to   inform  women  about  the  need  to  be  registered  on  the  civil  register.  In  2013,  the  percentage  of  women   on  the  civil  register   increased  from  76%  to  79%.  57.95%  of  the  women  who  received  assistance  live   in   Barcelona   and   42.05%   in   or   around   the  metropolitan   area.   The   reasons   for   not   being   registered   are:   users   who   live   outside   the   municipality   of   Barcelona,   who   share   housing   with   other   people   (shared   rooms   or   apartments)   or   possess   no   document   that   can   accredit   their   identity   and   enable   them   to   complete  the  procedure.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     11       2.6.  Accompaniment  to  resources  and  interventions     Accompaniment     We   speak   of  accompaniment   to   refer   to   the   process   of   personally   accompanying  women   to   services.   Accompaniment  is  a  highly  valued  tool,  which  not  only  guarantees  that  women  attend  and  are  receive   assistance   from   the   service,   but   also   enables   them   to   form   close   relationships   with   the   educator,   psychologist,   social   worker   or   health   worker   and   facilitates   the   establishment   of   a   link   between   the   women   and   the   service,   since   they   have   the   chance   to   speak   to   a   professional   from   the   team   in   an   environment  away  from  the  street  and  any  possible  control.       ACCOMPANIMENT   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   %   increase   compared  to   2006   Numbers   52   207   347   334   624   758   677   647   1,144.23%     Most  of   the   accompaniment   that   the   SAS  provides   continues   to  be,   as   in   2012,   to  organisations  with   which  the  ABITS  Agency  has  some  kind  of  link,  as  well  as  to  city  services  (85%),  mainly  health,  education,   citizen  assistance  and  justice.       Due  to  fact  that  many  users  of  the  service  live  in  the  metropolitan  area  or  in  towns  further  out,  15%  of   the   accompaniment   interventions   provided   by   the   SAS   take   place   in   other   municipalities,   mostly   in   L’Hospitalet  de  Llobregat  and  Santa  Coloma  de  Gramenet,  also,  in  the  main,  to  social  and  social  health   centres.   In   2012,   accompaniment   interventions   outside   the   city   accounted   for   12%   of   the   total.   The   team  attempts  to  link  women  to  services  in  their  own  residential  areas,  a  task  that  requires  considerable   effort  in  terms  of  work  time.       For  the  second  consecutive  year,  there  was  a  slight  fall   in  the  number  of  accompaniments,  a  decrease   that  can  be  attributed  to  several  reasons:     - Efforts  aimed  at  empowering  the  women  and  making  them  more  independent.     - Users’   increased   knowledge   about   the   various   organisations   with   which   the   Agency   has   established  cooperation  agreements,  making  accompaniment  unnecessary.     - The   impossibility   of   Romanian   women   to   enter   programmes   of   integration   into   employment   because,  despite  their  status  as  European  citizens  and  the  fact  that  they  have  residence  permits,   Spain’s   moratorium   on   ratifying   international   treaties   means   that   they   cannot   obtain   work   permits.     Interventions  conducted     Following   intervention   in   the   street,   an   initial   introductory   interview  with   the   social  worker   is   usually   arranged  at  the  SAS  office,  with  the  participation  of  the  psychologist  if  necessary.  Based  on  the  woman’s   request   for   assistance   and   the   needs   detected,   she   is   then   provided  with   information,   guidance   and   psychological  and  social  assistance.   Whilst   most   of   the   resources   provided   by   the   service   are   human   in   nature,   the   SAS   also   provides   occasional   financial  aid  to  enable  women  to  complete  processes  and  achieve  objectives  established   in   the  work   plans.   This   aid  may   be   provided   on   an   emergency,   one-­‐off   basis,   or   in   the   form   of   regular   payments  strictly  and  directly   related   to   the  work  plan.  The   total  amount  of  such  aid  provided  by   the   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     12       SAS  in  2013  was  12,301.65  euros,  distributed  as  follows:  39  grants  awarded  to  a  value  of  8,403.93  euros;   and  261  payments  of  lower  amounts  in  the  form  of  emergency  aid  to  a  total  value  of  3,897.72  euros.     2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   %   change   2012-­‐2013   Referrals  to  the  SAS   (received) -­‐   -­‐   92   73   85   65   61   60   -­‐1.64%   Referrals  to  other   services  and   organisations   83   278   329   321   436   493   453   577   27.37%   Coordination 193   613   1,096   1,458   2,183   2,360   2,726   3,461   26.96%   Interviews  at  the  office9     (not  including  psychological   assistance  interviews) 21   69   193   283   396   371   313   789   252.07%     There  was  a  significant   increase   (26.96%)   in   the  number  of  coordination  operations  between  services,   both  internal  (within  the  SAS  itself)  and  external  (by  phone  or  email).  This  increase  was  due,  in  the  main,   to  the  efforts  of  the  social  worker,  who  works  full  time,  enabling  weekly  coordination  meetings  with  the   psychologist  and  all   the  educators   that   form  part  of   the  service   in  order   to   jointly  assess   the  progress   made  in  individual  work  plans  and  to  establish  new  lines  of  intervention  and  goals  that  users  should  be   set.  Some  85%  of  coordination  measures  are  with  organisations  and  services  based  in  Barcelona,  whilst   the  remaining  15%  are  with  services  and  organisations  in  other  municipalities,  mainly  social  services  and   health  care  centres.       PSYCHOLOGICAL   ASSISTANCE   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   %   change   2012-­‐2013   Women  assisted   11   48   33   57   63   10.52%   New  women  assisted   -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐   -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐   -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐   38   29   -­‐23.68%   Telephone  assistance   24   110   170   292   334   14.38%   Interviews   29   143   230   349   448   28.37%       The  increase  in  the  number  of  interviews,  psychological  assistance  provided  and  cases  opened  is  due  to   the   rise   in   the   number   of   hours   worked   by   the   psychologist,   the   provision   of   information   about   the   existence   of   the   Psychological   Assistance   service   and   the   careful   and   specific   assistance   provided   by   what  is  a  specialist  service  with  its  own  particular  focus.     In  2013,  there  were  29  new  cases,  as  well  as  31  continuing  from  2012  and  5  reopened  cases.  Despite  the   decrease   in   the   number   of   new   cases   in   2013,   the   number   of   women   whose   cases   continue   to   be   monitored  rose.  In  2013,  12  psychological  assistance  files  were  closed,  6  due  to  the  fact  that  the  goals   had  been  achieved,  the  other  6  due  to  referral  to  other  psychological  assistance  services.                                                                                                                 9  Conducted  by  the  social  educators  and  the  social  worker.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     13         The  consolidation  of  the  psychological  assistance  service  in  2013  is  considered  a  highly  positive  advance.   The   service   provided   assistance   to   63   different   cases   in   2013,   with   6   closed   as   the   goals   had   been   achieved.   It   is  also  significant  that  56  of  these  women  were  or  had  been  victims  of  gender  violence   in   one   of   other   of   its   forms.   Another   significant   development   is   the   role   played   by   psychological   accompaniment   in   employment   relocation   processes,   with   43   of   the   63   women   engaged   in   such   initiatives.       Moreover,   interventions   in   the   office   by   the   social   worker   explore   indicators   in   order   to   determine   whether  or  not  the  woman  is  in  a  situation  of  human  trafficking  for  purposes  of  sexual  exploitation.  In   2013,   five  women   in   this   situation  were   identified,   and  work  with   them   focused   explicitly   on   helping   them   to   self-­‐identify   as   victims   and   guiding   them   through   the   decision-­‐making   process.   With   other   women,  the  service  focused  on  such  situations  indirectly,  gathering  information.     In   2013,   in   order   to   strengthen  users’   relationship  with   the   team  and   to   encourage  positive   relations   amongst  the  women  themselves,  the  SAS  organised  a  series  of  leisure  and  cultural  activities,  as  well  as   others  aimed  at  enabling  users  to   learn  more  about  the  host  country:  Christmas  party  (in  cooperation   with  El  Lloc  de  la  Dona  and  APIP),  Epiphany  party  (children’s  entertainment),  picnic  at  Vallvidrera,  visit  to   the   exhibition   Feminicidios.   No   nos   cabe   tanta   muerte,   about   the   situation   in   Ciudad   Juárez   (Casa   Elizalde),   making   roses   for   Saint   George’s   Day,   trip   to   the   beach   (Montgat)   and   film   forum   (three   sessions).       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     14       2.7.  Networking     Guidance  for  professionals     The   SAS   team   provides   guidance   for   municipal   service   workers   with   regard   to   people   engaged   in   prostitution  or  who  may   victims  of   human   trafficking   for   the  purpose  of   sexual   exploitation.   In   2013,   consultancy  services  were  provided  on  56  occasions  (45  to  other  services  and  11  to  students).  The  SAS   also  received  visits  from  students  and  professionals  from  Norway,  Chile,  Portugal  and  the  United  States.     The  team  regularly  liaises  with  the  City  Police  and,  when  necessary,  with  other  police  forces.     The  service  continues  to  respond  to  requests  and  to  give  presentations  where  requested,  and  forms  part   of  several  working  groups,  such  as  that  devoted  to  prostitution  and  AIDS  established  by  the  Government   of   Catalonia’s   Ministry   of   Health   and   El   Raval   district   Community   Health   Group.   The   team   also   participates  in  three  of  the  city’s  territorial  circuits  against  violence  towards  women.       Police  operations       Since   December   2011,  within   the   framework   of   the   government  measure,   the   ABITS   Agency’s   Socio-­‐ Educational   Service   (SAS)   has   provided   assistance   for   women   during   the   course   of   police   operations   related  to  engagement  in  prostitution  or  other  motives.  The  results  of  the  first  two  years’  work  in  this   field  are  considered  to  be  excellent.     To  assist  women  in  such  circumstances,  the  SAS  is  provided  with  a  prepaid  bundle  of  200  hours  devoted   to  social  education,  available  24  hours  a  day,  365  days  a  year.     In  2013,  the  SAS  took  part  in  a  total  of  14  operations  (the  same  number  as  in  the  previous  year),  12  in   Les  Corts  district  courts,  1  in  Ciutat  Vella  and  1  a  large-­‐scale  operation  involving  the  Catalan  police,  the   City  Police,  the  Employment  Inspectorate,  Chinese  interpreters  and  the  SAS  itself  due  to  the  activation   of   the  protocol   for   the  protection  of  victims  of  human  trafficking   in  Catalonia.  This  operation  entailed   inspections  of  40  hairdressing  and  beauty  salons  run  by  Chinese  people,  aimed  at  detecting  victims  of   human  trafficking  for  purposes  of  labour  and/or  sexual  exploitation.         The  objectives  of  participation  in  such  operations  are  as  follows:       - To  inform  the  women  about  the  SAS,  if  they  are  not  aware  of  its  existence,  and  to  enable  them   to  access  the  service.     - To  detect  possible  situations  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  and  to   offer  the  protection  and  shelter  services  provided  by  the  Agency.     - To   detect   situations   of   special   vulnerability   or   needs   that   require   immediate   attention   (medication,  family  responsibilities,  emotional  containment,  etc.).     - To  ensure  that  the  women  understand  the  situation  and  are  aware  of  their  rights  and  duties.       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     15       3.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in   enclosed  spaces  (bars,  clubs  and  apartments)     3.1.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in  the   Eixample  district     The  objective  of  this  programme  is  to  reach  out  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in   the  Eixample  district  in  order  to  identify  situations  of  vulnerability,  to  offer  health  and  social  assistance   and  guidance,  to  attend  to  their  needs  comprehensively  and  to  refer  them  to  programmes  run  by  the   ABITS   Agency,   the   partner   organisation   involved   or   services   provided   by   other   organisations.   The   programme   takes   into   account   both   factors   specific   to   these   women   and   the   types   of   services   and   practices  found  in  such  locales.     The  programme  was  launched  on  1  October  2013  with  a  search  for  clubs,  the  preparation  of  materials   and   the   provision   of   assistance   circuits   for   the   women,   as   well   as   coordination   with   various   organisations  devoted   to  providing   social  and  health   resources.  On  17  October  2013,   the   team  began   visiting  apartments,  clubs  and  bars  in  the  Eixample  district  of  Barcelona.     Public  hours  are  Monday  and  Thursday,  from  10  am  to  14  pm,  and  Tuesdays,  Wednesdays  and  Fridays,   from  4  to  8  pm.  During  these  times,  two  days  per  week  are  devoted  to  visiting  locales,  whilst  the  other   days  are  used  to  provide  individual,  confidential  assistance  at  the  offices  of  the  partner  organisation.  On   Wednesdays,   the   team   goes   out   from   8   pm   to   midnight   in   order   to   reach   women   engaged   in   prostitution  in  bars  and  apartments  at  night.  The  telephone  helpline  provided  operates  from  Monday  to   Friday,  from  10  am  to  10  pm.     The   approach  used   is   based  on  direct   intervention,   offering   resources   and   services   in   situ.   Parallel   to   this,   individual   interventions  are  carried  out   for  women  who  request  this  at   the  office  and/or  through   accompaniment  to  different  resources  and  services  in  the  network.     The  resources  allocated  to  the  programme  are:  the  programme  coordinator,  a  social  worker  (20  hours   per  week)  as  programme  leader,  a  manager  with  a  background  in  healthcare  (12  hours  per  week)  and   three  volunteers  (health  workers).     Actions  implemented     The   programme   resulted   in   the   identification   of   95   enclosed   spaces:   39   clubs,   51   bars,   3   massage   parlours  and  2  unspecified  locales.       In  October,  November  and  December  the  organisation  made  41  visits  to  30  different  enclosed  spaces  in   order  to  provide  information  about  the  service.  Except  for  two  clubs  and  one  apartment,  there  were  no   difficulties   in   accessing   the   locales   and   contacting   the   women.   Indeed,   most   of   the   locales   explicitly   requested   that   the   service   should  make   regular   visits.  Most  of   the  women  who   run   the  premises   are   older  than  the  women  engaged  in  prostitution  there,  and  are  the  only  ones  with  employment  contracts.   The  locales  are  usually  owned  by  men.  One  proprietor,  who  owns  two  clubs,  requested  the  presence  of   the   service.  At   locales   considered   "luxury",   the  presence  of  private   security   companies  was  observed,   with  between  three  and  six  people  at  the  door  and  fewer  (almost  nonexistent)  requests  put  forward  by   the  women  themselves.       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     16       During  these  visits,  178  women  were  counted  and  contact  was  made  with  141  (some  women  may  have   been   counted  or   contacted  more   than  once).  A   total   of   605  male   condoms  and  136   female   condoms   were   distributed,   as   well   as   lubricants.   At   December   31,   the   team   was   assisting   and   individually   monitoring  a  total  of  45  women,  all  of  whom  had  been  interviewed  at  the  SAS  office  and  accompanied   to  resources  and  referred  to  other  services.     Eight  liaison  meetings  took  place  with  different  bodies  in  order  to  establish  a  protocol  for  the  provision   of   assistance   to   the   women,   and  meetings   with   different   organisations   and   services   were   also   held,   whist  coordination  with  social  and  health  resources  was  established  by  telephone.       The  consumption  of  alcohol  and  other  drugs  (usually  cocaine)  is  a  common  practice  among  the  women,   who  use  such  substances  as  a  means  of  escape  and  to  endure  the  hours   in  which  they  are  engaged  in   the  practice.   In  many  cases,  moreover,   their  clients  ask   them  to  consume  such  substances   in  order   to   make   them   lose   their   inhibitions   and   engage   in   more   high-­‐risk   sexual   practices   that   they   would   not   agree  to  in  other  circumstances.       It  was  observed  that  the  women  change  locale  within  the  same  city  frequently  and  that  some  also  move   from   one   city   or   country   to   another.  Many  women,   although   they   have   lived   in   Barcelona   for   some   years,   have   difficulties   in   getting   around   in   the   city,   for   which   reason  many   need   accompaniment   in   order  to  reach  services.     Sociodemographic  profile       The   average   age  of   the  45  women  monitored   in   2013  was  33   years;   the   youngest  was  19,  whilst   the   oldest  was  42  years  of  age.     AGE   2013  %   Under  25  years   11.0   25-­‐30  years   20.0   31-­‐40  years   46.5   Over  40   9.0   No  information   13.0     Regarding   the   origin   of   the  women  monitored,   there  were   no   African  women,  whilst   Latin-­‐American   women  were  the  largest  group.                             ORIGIN   2013  %   Migrant   93.5   National   6.5   ORIGIN     2013  %   Latin  America   69.0   Eastern  Europe   22.0   Spanish   6.5   Arabic  countries   2.0   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     17                                     Requests     Many  women  explained  that  there  are  customers  who  request  sex  without  a  condom  and  are  willing  to   pay  more  in  order  to  carry  out  this  higher-­‐risk  behaviour.  These  women  request  more  female  condoms   than  those  engaged   in  prostitution   in   the  street.  Some  women  requested   training   in  using   the   female   condom,  and  workshops  were  held  in  situ.  Other  women  requested  information  about  what  to  do  if  the   condom  breaks.                     Interventions  and  referrals     In  response  to  the  women’s  requests,  two  types  of  intervention  were  conducted:   ⎯ group   interventions   at   clubs   and   in   apartments:   information   about   drugs,   prevention   of   unwanted  pregnancies,  prevention  of  HIV  and  other  sexually   transmitted  diseases,  use  of   the   female  condom,  and   information  about   the  health  card  and   the  network  of   social  and  health   resources  in  the  city.   ⎯ Individual   interventions  at  Red  Cross  offices:  10  individual   interviews  with  women  at  Red  Cross   headquarters  in  order  to  gain  greater  understanding  of  their  situation  in  a  confidential  setting,   15  accompaniments   to  health   resources   (gynaecology),   language  normalisation  centre  and  11   referrals  to  resources  and  services  provided  by  other  organisations,  as  well  as  SAIER,  Anem  per   feina,   the   SARA   pre-­‐employment   project,   the   Kit   food   programme,   the   campaign   for   toys   at   Christmas,  Àmbit  dona  and  the  ABITS  Agency’s  SAS.     ADMINISTRATIVE  SITUATION   2013  %   Regular   73.50   Irregular   13.00   Community   13.50   HEALTH  CARD   2013  %   Yes   78   No   20   DK/NR   2   GENDER   2013  %   Women   87   Transsexuals   13   TYPE  OF  REQUEST   (the  same  woman  may  make   more  than  one  type  of   request)   2013   Number  of   women       Health   40   Legal   9   Employment   6   Social   6   TOTAL   61   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     18       The  intervention  programme  run  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  the  Eixample  district  to  assist  women  engaged   in  prostitution   in  bars,  apartments  and  clubs   is   implemented  under  a  cooperation  agreement  with  the   Red  Cross  organisation.       3.2.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in  Les  Corts   district       The  objective   of   this   programme,   launched   in   July   2013,   is   to   form  a   picture   of   the   circumstances   of   women  and  transsexual  people  engaged  in  prostitution  in  clubs  in  Les  Corts  district,  to  learn  about  their   characteristics  and  to  define  priorities  for  intervention:  contacting  the  women,  advising  them  about  the   services   and   resources   available,   studying   their   circumstances,   detecting   any   situations   of   forced   prostitution  and/or  violence  and  establishing  a  protocol  of  action  for  the  intervention.  Another  objective   was   to   learn   about   alternative,   de-­‐localised   models   of   engagement   in   prostitution   (use   of   the   new   technologies)  and  to  review  existing  studies.     Using   different   search   engines   (list   of   locales   provided   by   the   district,   search   engines   specialised   in   sexual   services,  discussion   forums  aimed  at  clients,  websites  of   locales,  professional  blogs,  newspaper   contact  sections,  taxi  drivers,  sex  shops,  women  known  to  the  organisations)  an  exploration  was  made   of  the  enclosed  spaces  in  Les  Corts  district.  This  search  enabled  the  team  to  draw  up  a  list  of  locales  and   apartments,   to   pinpoint   their   location   and   to   gather   information   for   an   initial   outreach   stage.   Considerable  difficulty  was  encountered   in  obtaining   the  exact   location  of   such   locales,  particularly   in   the  case  of  apartments.     The  locales  were  classified  into  four  categories:       -­‐ Clubs:  with  bar  service  and  entrance  from  the  street.   -­‐ “Relax”:  erotic  massage  service  with  possibility  of  sexual  services.   -­‐ Peep   show/X   cinema:   locales   where   erotic   shows   take   place   and   women   also   offer   sexual   services  to  clients.   Includes  X   film  projection  rooms  where  women  engage   in  prostitution  with   clients.   -­‐ Apartments:  use  of  apartments  in  blocks  of  flats  for  the  purpose  of  providing  sexual  services.                       A   total   of   29  enclosed   spaces  were   identified.  Although   it  was  not  possible   to   visit   them  all,   contacts   were  made  with  the  owners  and  it  was  noted  that  they  all  continued  to  operate.  Finally,  fourteen  of  the   locales  identified  were  visited.  We  should  note  that  eight  of  these  enclosed  spaces  (four  clubs  and  four   apartments)  did  not  allow  the  team  to  have  access  or  contact  with  the  women.  On  the  other  hand,  two   apartments  and  three  clubs  asked  the  organisation  to  make  return  visits.  One  apartment  and  one  club   were  not  visited  in  order  not  to  duplicate  the  intervention  of  another  organisation.     The  social  educators  went  out  on  several  occasions,  making  visits  that  enabled  them  to  establish  initial   contact  with   the   locales   operating.  Generally   speaking,   those   in   charge   of   these   establishments  were   helpful  in  arranging  contact  with  the  women  and  enabling  the  visits  to  take  place.  A  total  of  60  women   were  contacted  in  24  visits  (some  women  may  have  been  contacted  more  than  once).  The  second  visit   ENCLOSED  SPACES   IDENTIFIED   2013   Number     Clubs   10   Relax   2   Peep  show/X  cinema     2   Apartments   15   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     19       to  each  locale  was  made  at  a  different  time  to  the  first  in  order  to  contact  different  women.  As  contacts   were  established  with  different  locales,  it  was  noted  that  some  women  were  already  being  assisted  by   organisations  specialising  in  providing  services  for  women  engaged  in  prostitution.       At  31  December  2013,  the  service  was  individually  monitoring  17  different  women.     Sociodemographic  information     The  17  women  monitored  presented  heterogeneous  profiles.  Their  ages  were  between  20  and  40  years,   except   for   one   apartment,  where   the  women  were   over   65   years   old.   The  women   came   from   Spain,   Argentina,  Brazil,  Romania,  Colombia,  Dominican  Republic,  China  and  Peru.  The  Latin  women  were  the   most  numerous,  followed  by  those  from  the  Eastern  European  countries,  Spain  and  China.     Requests       Most  of  the  requests  put  forward  by  the  women  concerned  health  (particularly  gynaecology)  and  many   interventions  and  accompaniments  were  made   for   this   reason.  Other   requests  were   related   to   sexual   and   reproductive   education,   psychological   assistance   and   emotional   support,   prevention   of   drug   consumption   and   resources   to   deal  with  high-­‐risk   situations.  Higher   levels   of   drug   consumption  were   noted  amongst   these  women   than  amongst   those  who  engage   in  prostitution   in   the   street  and   some   were  already  under   treatment  at   services  specialising   in  addictions.  Some  women  who  had  requested   assistance  pulled  out  at  the  last  minute  and  it  was  impossible  to  schedule  interventions  with  them.                             Analysis  and  review  of  studies     In   September   2013,  with   the   aim  of   obtaining   information   about   “de-­‐localised”   prostitution,   contacts   were  made  with  a  working  group  with  experience  in  the  subject  at  the  University  of  the  Balearic  Islands   (Balearic   Islands   Research   Study   Group,   GEPIB).   More   specifically,   contact   was   made   with   Dr   Lluís   Ballester,  who  leads  a  study  into  “de-­‐localised”  prostitution.  The  study  emphasises  the  use  of  the  new   technologies   to   attract   and   contact   clients,   the   role   of   supply   and   demand   and   the   difficulty   of   establishing  contacts  with  the  women  involved.     It   was   impossible   to   contact   any   women   who   worked   by   offering   sexual   services   on   independent   websites,  or   to   learn   their  modus  operandi.  The  difficulty   in  achieving   this   lies   in   the   fact   that,  before   contacting   the   woman,   prior   payment   must   be   made   and,   when   the   organisation   identified   itself,   communication  was  blocked.     REQUESTS   2013  Number     Sexual  and  reproductive   health   20   Training   3   Integration  into   employment   2   Primary  social  assistance   3   INTERVENTIONS  AND   ACCOMPANIMENT   2013   Number     Sexual  and  reproductive   health   21   Integration  into   employment   1   Social  assistance   2   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     20       The   ABITS   Agency   programme   for   intervention   in   Les   Corts   district   as   a   strategic   line   for   providing   assistance   to   women   engaged   in   prostitution   in   bars,   apartments   and   clubs   was   launched   in   the   framework  of   a   cooperation  agreement  with   the  Oblate   Sisters  organisation’s  El   Lloc  de   la  Dona   (The   Place  for  Women)  project.         3.3.  Assistance  to  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  enclosed  spaces  in  the  other   districts  of  the  city     This  programme,  aimed  at  people  who  engage  in  prostitution  in  apartments  and  locales,  providing  them   with   information   about   the   services   and   resources   available   to   them,   was   launched   on   24   February   2011.  Under  the  initiative,  regular  visits  are  made  to  premises  where  prostitution  takes  place,  contacting   the  women  involved,  detecting  needs  and  requests,   identifying  situations  of  vulnerability  and  violence   and  providing  comprehensive  assistance.     In   2013,   the   educators   visited   a   total   of   19   locales   (13   apartments   and   six   clubs).   In   2012,   31   locales   were  visited,  15  already  known  from  previous  years  and  16  for  the  first  time.  It  was  noted  in  these  visits   that  the  trend  of  opening  self-­‐managed  locales  run  by  the  women  themselves  continued  to  rise.       In  total,  assistance  was  provided  to  162  women  in  57  apartments,  28  clubs  and  3  singles  bars.  Most  of   these  women   approached   the   programme   of   their   own   volition   and   initiative.   Accordingly,   then,   the   programme  covers  88  enclosed  spaces  in  the  city  of  Barcelona.     As  the  table  below  shows,  there  was  a  significant  increase  in  assistance  provided  to  women  engaged  in   prostitution  in  open  spaces  in  2013  compared  to  the  previous  year:       WOMEN  PROVIDED  WITH   ASSISTANCE   2012   2012   2013   2013   %   Number   %   Number   Clubs  and  apartments   74.6%   226   48.01%   162   Public  way   25.4%   77   51.90%   175   TOTAL   100%   303   100%   337     In  2013,  a   total  of  415  women  were  contacted.   Including  those  engaged   in   the  activity   in  both  closed   and   open   spaces.   Of   these   415   women,   337   (81.20%   of   the   women   contacted)   were   assisted   and   monitored   through   1,322   interventions   (individual   interviews,   accompaniment,   referrals   to   other   resources,  etc.).   It   should  be  noted   that  282  of   the  415  women   (47.16%)  were  contacted   for   the   first   time  in  2013.     In  2012,  852  women  were  contacted  and  a  lower  number,  a  total  of  303,  were  monitored.  These  women   were  the  subject  of  1,088  actions  in  2012,  when  151  (18%)  were  contacted  for  the  first  time.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     21       Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  women  who  received  assistance     By   nationality,   the   largest   group   amongst   the   337   women   (44.51%)   came   from   Latin   America,   particularly   Ecuador   (10.08%),   Dominican   Republic   (9.49%),   Colombia   (8.90%)   and   Brazil   (3.85%).   The   next  most   numerous   group  was   formed  by  women   from   Sub-­‐Saharan  Africa   (26.70%),  mainly  Nigeria   (25.22%).  Women  from  Eastern  Europe  accounted  for  47%  and  were  mostly  from  Romania  (9.79%)  and   Russia  (2.97).  Spanish  nationals  accounted  for  6.82%,  Moroccans  3.26%  and  Chinese  1.19%.     By   age,   the   23-­‐27   year   group   accounted   for   24.9%  of   the   total,   those   from  28   to   32   years,   19%,   and   those  from  18  to  22  years,  16%.       Requests     The  most  common  request  put  forward  by  the  women,  both  those  from  enclosed  and  open  spaces,  was   for   legal   assistance.   These   women  were   provided  with   information,   legal   advice   and,   in   some   cases,   services  with  regard  to  immigration  issues  and  criminal  law.     Secondly,  and  as  a  gateway  to  working  on  other  issues,  assistance  was  provided  with  regard  to  requests   in   the   field   of   health   (prevention   of   sexually   transmitted   diseases,   use   of   condoms,   etc.).   The   trend   towards   increasingly  unsafe   sexual  practices  and  concern  about   sexual  health  continued.  Situations   in   which   women   were   the   victims   of   gender   violence   were   also   detected,   and   users   in   such   situations   received  priority  attention.  Finally,  the  women  also  made  frequent  requests  related  to  integration  Into   employment.         REQUESTS   2012   %   2013   %   Health   63%   37.75%   Legal   19%   52.12%   Social  assistance  or  situations   of  violence   18%   10.23%   TOTAL  CASES   1,088   1,322     Although   most   resources   employed   were   the   agency’s   own   services,   which   accounted   for   71.86%   (59.09%   in   2012),   referrals   were   also  made   in   the   field   of   health   (to   primary   assistance   centres   and   hospitals),  social  resources  (ABITS-­‐SAS,  El  Lloc  de  la  Dona,  Anem  per  feina  and  the  Surt  Foundation)  and   legal  services  (prosecutors,  law  enforcement  bodies,  SICAR.cat),  amongst  others.       The  ABITS  Agency’s   programme   for   intervention   in   other   districts   of   the   city   to   provide   assistance   to   women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  clubs  and  apartments  described  in  this  section  is  implemented  within   the  framework  of  a  cooperation  agreement  with  the  Genera  Association  for  Women’s  Rights.             State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     22       4.  Other  social  assistance  services     4.1.  Intervention  and  assistance  for  women  in  situations  of  intermediate   emergency  and  social  inclusion     Since  2006,  Barcelona  City  Council  has  provided  intermediate  emergency  support  to  women  in  specific   situations  through  the  provision  of  one-­‐off,   immediate  attention  to  minimise  the  risks  of   the  situation   and   the   vulnerability   observed.   In   2010,   the   programme   was   expanded   and   became   known   as   intervention   in   intermediate   emergencies   and   social   inclusion.  Moreover   support   for   shared   housing   and  workshops  for  Nigerian  single-­‐parent  families  were  included  in  the  programme  provisions.     Financial  aid     Over   the  course  of  2013,  a   total  of  154  direct  economic  grants  were  provided   to  assist  52  people   (50   women  and  2   female   transsexual  people),   22  of  whom   (42.31%  of   the   total)   received  more   than  one   grant.   In   2012,   130   grants   were   provided   to   assist   51   people   (48   women   and   3   female   transsexual   people).     The   programme   provides   for   the   possibility   that   the   women   can   return   some   of   the   aid   (loan   repayment)  when   their   economic   situation   allows   them   to   do   so,   although  most   cannot   due   to   their   precarious   socio-­‐economic   situation.   As   a   result,   250   euros   were   repaid   from   the   total   aid   granted,   which  rose  to  a  total  of  8,920.70  euros   .       FINANCIAL  AID   2012   2012   2013   2013   Amount  in   euros   Number  of   grants   Amount  in  euros   Number  of   grants   Housing   3,350.00   21   4,430.00   22   Administrative   procedures   2,865.16   25   2,764.80   31   Health   1,251.45   19   849.00   16   Travel   622.15   65   876.00   85   TOTAL   8,088.76   130   8,920.70   154       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     23       The  following  table  shows  the  sociodemographic  profiles  of  the  women  who  received  this  aid.     PROFILE     2012   2013   Origen   90%   (46   women)   from   Sub-­‐Saharan   Africa     The   remaining   10%  were   two   Spanish   nationals,   two   Brazilian   women   and   one  Moroccan  national   78.72%  (41  women)  from  Sub-­‐Saharan   Africa   7.69%  (4  women)  from  Latin  America   7.69%  (4  women)  from  Eastern  Europe     The   remaining   5.9%   corresponded   to   two  women  from  the  Maghreb  and  one   Spanish  national     Administrativ e  situation   57%  (29  women)  in  regular  situation   67.31%  (35  women)  in  regular  situation   Age    70%   (36  women)   between   20   and   29   years      30%   (15  women)   between   30   and   45   years     61.53%  (32  women)  between  31  and  40   years     28.84%  (15  women)  between  20  and  30   years      9.61%  (5  women)  over  41  years     Children   under  charge   93%  (47  women)  have  children     83%  (42  women)  are  single  women     73.07%  (38  women)  have  children  under   their  charge   73.07%  (38  women)  are  single  women   26.92%  (14  women)  live  with  a  partner   Education   level   No  data  available   48.07%  (25  women)  secondary  studies   26.92%  (14  women)  primary  studies   15.38%  (8  women)  vocational   training/university   9.61%   (5  women)   can   neither   read   nor   write     Shared  housing     The  shared  housing  was  occupied  by  four  adult  women  and  two  children  (one  aged  seven  years  and  one   aged  three,   the  children  of   two  of   the  women)   for  periods  of  3-­‐17  months.  All   these  people  began  to   receive  assistance  from  the  service  in  2012.  In  all  cases,  the  women  were  monitored  by  the  service.  The   cost   of   this   resource   in   terms   of   rent   and   utilities   was   4,340   euros,   of   which   the   women   paid   150,   leaving  total  expenditure  of  4,280  euros.     Workshops     In   2013,   a   total   of   7  workshops  were   organised,   2   in   April   (6  women)   and   a   second   in   September   (5   women)   with   a   total   duration   of   20   hours   spread   over   5   sessions.   During   the   months   of   October,   November  and  December,  4  more  workshops  were  organised  for  13  women  referred  by  the  SAS.  These   consisted  of  12  hours,  spread  over  3  sessions  of  4  hours  each,  with  the  participation  of  a  psychologist,  a   social  worker  and  a  student  social  worker  on  work  practice.       This   programme   of   assistance   for   women   in   intermediate   emergencies   and   social   inclusion   is   implemented  within  the  framework  of  a  cooperation  agreement  with  the  Àmbit  Prevenció  (Prevention   Area)  Foundation.         State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     24       4.2.  “Socio-­‐sanitary  pills”  for  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  the  public  way     This   programmed  was   established   to   promote   the   prevention   of   socio-­‐sanitary   risks   amongst   people   engaged  in  prostitution  in  Barcelona  with  the  aim  of  improving  their  state  of  health,  using  education  as  a   tool   for   change   and   transformation,   and   in   response   to   the   great   demand   from   the   women   for   information  and  assistance  in  this  field.     In  2013,  the  outreach  service  went  out  on  16  occasions,  delivering  92  information  sessions  or  "pills"  in   the   street   to   a   total   of   151   women.   Moreover,   7   training   actions   also   took   place,   with   an   average   attendance  of  8  people  per  session  (24  in  total,  mostly  women  of  Nigerian  origin).     The  subjects  discussed  at   the   information  sessions   included  healthy  habits,   the  prevention  of   sexually   transmitted   diseases   and   unwanted   pregnancies,   reducing   harm   caused   by   drug   use   and   preventing   gender  violence.       The  programme  on  health  care  and  prevention  is  implemented  through  a  cooperation  agreement  with   the  organisation  Doctors  of  the  World  (Metges  del  Món).     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     25       5.  Services  and  training  resources  for  training  and   integration  into  employment       5.1.  DIR  Comprehensive  programme  for  the  re-­‐employment  of  women  engaged   in  prostitution     The   objective   of   the   DIR   re-­‐employment   programme   is   to   provide   a   response   to   women   who,   from   personal  choice,  wish  to  give  up  prostitution  and  start  out  in  a  different  activity.  The  range  of  resources   offered  by  the  DIR  programme  enables  each  of  the  women  who  participate  in  it  to  design  and  put  into   practice   their   own   professional   projects,   to   develop   professional   skills   and   to   improve   their   employability  with  regard  to  the  labour  market,  their  employment  goal  and  the  job  they  would   like  to   find.   The   programme   has   a   large   resource   bank   enabling   circuits   to   be   adjusted   to   each   woman   individually  in  accordance  with  their  needs.       The  data  for  the  period  from  January  to  December  2013  include  three  editions  of  the  DIR  programme,   with  a  total  of  four  groups:     -­‐  Edition  2     -­‐ GROUP  2:     ⎯ Data   from   January   2013   to   April   2013   (the   women   had   started   the   process   in   May   2012).   -­‐ GROUP  3:   ⎯ Data   from   January   2013   to   August   2013   (the   women   had   started   the   process   in   September  2012).     -­‐  Edition  3  (Annex  1)   -­‐ GROUP  4:     ⎯ Data   from  April  2013   to  December  2013   (the  women  had  started   the  process   in  2013   and  will  complete  it  in  March  2014).     -­‐  Edition  4  (Annex  2)   -­‐ GROUP  5:     ⎯ Data   from   September   2013   to   December   2013   (the   women   started   the   process   in   September  2013  and  will  complete  it  in  August  2014).         DIR  EDITION  2     GROUPS  2  and  3.  Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  two  groups     The  initial  data  for  both  groups,  for  which  a  total  of  40  women  were  selected,  were  jointly  analysed.  The   Group   2   process   began   in  May   2012   and   ended   in  March   2013,  whilst   the  Group  3   process   began   in   September  2012  and  ended  in  August  2013.     Thirty-­‐five  of  the  women  (87.50%)  were  migrants,  the  remaining  five  (12.5%)  Spanish  nationals.  A  new   development  in  2012  was  the  inclusion  of  women  of  Nigerian  origin  in  the  programme,  a  state  of  affairs   that  continued  in  2013.       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     26                                                   All   the  women  had   regularised   their   situations  administratively,   55%  with  European  Community  work   and   residence   permits,   22.50%   with   Community   residence   permits   but   without   work   permits,   and   22.50%  with  DNI  Spanish  national  identity  documents.     90%  had  children  or  other  people  under  their  charge,  25%  of  them  in  their  country  of  origin.     Of  the  40  women  selected  for  G2  and  G3  in  2012,  6  closed  the  process  in  2012,  3  dropping  out  and  3  by   agreement  (health  reasons,  pregnancy,  child  rearing).       The  G2  women  began  the  process  in  May  2012  and  completed  it  in  March/April  2013.  Of  the  25  women   who  entered   the  programme   in  2012,  one  dropped  out   in   the   first   two  months  and   two  more  did   so   between  the  third  and  sixth  month.  As  a  result,  at  1  January  2013,  21  women  continued  to  form  part  of   G2  in  the  DIR  programme.  When  the  course  ended  for  that  group,  11  of  the  21  women  were  proposed   for   another   programme   of   integration   into   employment   (ITI)   and   eight   were   registered   for   the   DIR   programme.       The  women  in  G3  began  the  DIR  process  in  September  2012  and  completed  it  in  August  2013.  Of  the  15   women  that  started  out  in  2012,  two  dropped  out  in  the  first  month  and  another  halfway  through  the   course.  The  remaining  13  women  completed  the  programme,  in  July  and  August  2013.       Accordingly,  then,  in  2013,  a  total  of  34  women  (21  in  G2  and  13  in  G3)  continued  the  process  and  were   still  active  participants  in  the  second  edition  of  the  DIR  programme.   MAIN   COUNTRIES   OF   ORIGIN   Data   from  G2  +  G3     %   Nigeria   30%   Romania   15%   Ecuador   15%   Spain   12.5%   Colombia   10%   AGE  GROUPS   Data  from  G2  +  G3   %   Under  25  years   2.5%   25-­‐35  years   52.5%   36-­‐45  years     25%   46-­‐65  years   20%   LEVEL  OF  STUDIES   Data  from  G2  +  G3   %   Primary     25%   Secondary   55%   University     20%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     27         ⎯ Implementation  of  professional  projects     The  activities  completed  by  the  women  in  G2  and  G·∙  were:         Activities  to  improve  skills   Number  of   women   G2  +  G3   Introductory  cookery  workshop  (six  women)   Introductory  chambermaid  workshop  (five  women)   11   Work  practice     9   Module  on  job  seeking  techniques     13   Computer  use  module   10   Catalan/Spanish  module   7   Module  to  develop  transversal  skills  of   identification,  coping,  relating     21   Module  on  job  seeking  techniques     29     Accompaniment  in  active  job  seeking     Number  of   women   G2  +  G3   Class  on  job  seeking,  technical  assistance     20   Module  to  monitor  job  seeking     29   Tutorials  to  provide  guidance  in  the  process  of  job   seeking   34   Tutorials  on  consolidating  and  retaining  employment     24     Employment  guidance   Number  of   women   G2  +  G3   Individual  legal  advice   6     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     28         ⎯ Cases  of  integration  into  employment:  G2  +  G3     DIR   G2   and   G3   enabled   24   women   to   be   integrated   into   the   formal   employment   market,   with   31   contracts,  a   figure  that  represents  71%  of  the  34  women  who  took  part   in  the  process.  Seven  women   were  integrated  into  employment  in  2013,  with  seven  employment  contracts.  Eleven  women  also  found   work   in  the   informal  employment  market  (the  same  woman  may  have  found  employment   in  both  the   formal  and  informal  markets).       Number  of   women   integrated  into   employment  G2  +   G3   Number  of   contracts   Occupation   24   31   2  assistant  librarians   3  nutrition  advisors   1  massage  assistant     7  chambermaids     1  seamstress   1  carer  for  elderly  people   2  shop  assistants   13  cleaners   1  blog  assistant     Of   the   24   women   integrated   into   employment   with   contracts,   15   had   children   in   their   charge   in   Barcelona.   In   58%   of   cases,   integration   Into   quality   employment   was   achieved   (14   women   with   contracts   for   over   six  months   and/or   integration   that  met   the   employment   goal   proposed).   42%   (10   women)  achieved  initial  integration  Into  Employment  (first  job).     51%  of   the  women  obtained  contracts  of  up   to  six  months  and  23%  contracts  of   six  months  or  more.   13%  were  temporary,  for  less  than  one  month,  or  short-­‐term  substitutions.  Non  of  the  women  in  G2  and   G3  received  permanent  contracts.       39%  of  the  jobs  were  full-­‐time,  whilst  58%  were  part-­‐time  contracts  of  20  hours  a  week  or  more  and  the   remaining  3%  corresponded  to  contracts  for  less  than  the  weekly  part-­‐time  rate  (4  hours  per  week).                               62%   of   the   women   who   found   work   did   so   through   the   organisation’s   mediation   and   internal   job   listings.  The  remaining  38%  of  women  integrated  into  employment  achieved  this  independently  and  by   putting  forward  their  own  job  applications.   It  should  be  noted  that  a   large  percentage  of  women  who   found  their  first  job  through  the  organisation’s  mediation  later  went  on  to  find  work  independently.     SECTORS  OF  INTEGRATION     Data  from  G2  +  G3   %   Services  to  companies  /  people   (cleaning)   29%   Hotels   25%   Education/libraries   22%   Commerce   14%   Textiles   4%   Health   6%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     29         22.2%   (two  women  out  of  nine)  who  did  work  practice  at   companies   in  2013   later   found  work  at   the   same  enterprise.     DIR  EDITION  3  (Annex  1)  Group  4     The  women  from  Group  4  began  the  process  in  April  2013  and  will  end  it  in  March  2014.  Data  from  April   2013  to  December  2013  is  analysed  here.       Of  the  37  women  referred,  25  were  finally  selected.  Those  that  were  not  selected  either  did  not  match   the  required  profile  or  ruled  themselves  out.       Of   the   25   women   selected,   24   were   still   continuing   the   process   at   31   December   2013,   whilst   one   dropped  out  by  mutual  agreement.                                                         76%  of  the  women  who  participated  in  Edition  3  of  DIR  had  children  or  other  people  in  their  charge.     62%   of   the   women   who   found   work   did   so   through   the   organisation’s   mediation   and   internal   job   listings.     MAIN  COUNTRIES  OF   ORIGIN     Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   National   20%   Migrant   80%   Latin   Ecuador   36%   16%   Sub-­‐Saharan   Nigeria   24%   16%   Eastern  Europe   Bulgaria   Russia   Romania   16%   8%   4%   4%   Morocco   4%   DOCUMENTATION   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Official  Spanish  ID   20%   Community  (residence)   8%   Community  (residence  and   work)   72%   AGE  GROUPS   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Under  25  years   0%   25-­‐35  years   36%   36-­‐45  years     56%   46  -­‐65  years   8%   LEVEL  OF  STUDIES   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Unschooled   8%   Primary     28%   Secondary   48%   University     4%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     30         ⎯ Actions  to  implement  the  professional  project     To  ensure   that  each  of   the  participating  women  could  develop   their  professional  projects   individually   and  at  their  own  rhythm,  a  range  of  resources  was  proposed:     TUTORIAL  TO  MONITOR   IMPLEMENTATION   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   Number  of   women   Definition  of  the  goal  of  integration   26   Definition  of  the   employment/professional  goal     26   Definition  of  the  training  goal     21   Definition  of  the  action  plan     25     ACTIONS  TO  IMPROVE  SKILLS   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   Number  of  women   Surt  Foundation  introductory  workshops   8  women:   -­‐ 3  chambermaids   -­‐ 2  customer  service   supermarket  workers   -­‐ 3  seamstresses     DIR-­‐TS  introductory  workshops   9  domestic  assistants   Online  training   9  food  handlers   Module  on  job  seeking  techniques     25     Computer  use  module   17   Catalan  module  (Consortium  for   Language  Normalisation)   16   Change  skill  module   9   Module  to  develop  transversal  skills  of   identification,  coping,  relating     18     Linked  to  processes  of   training  (domestic   assistants  and   seamstresses)  and   recruitment   Module  on  planning  the  search  for  jobs   19     EMPLOYMENT  ADVICE   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   Number  of   women   Group  employment  advice  module     18   individual  legal  advice   15     ACCOMPANIMENT  IN  ACTIVE  JOB  SEEKING   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   Number  of   women   Class  in  job  seeking,  technical  assistance     9   Modules  to  monitor  job  seeking   19   Tutorials  to  provide  guidance  in  the  job  seeking  process     22   Tutorials  on  consolidating  and  retaining  employment     13       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     31       ⎯ Cases  of  integration  into  employment     In  the  third  edition  of  DIR  (Group  4),  at  31  December  2013,  the  25  women  included  in  the  programme  at   the  beginning  had  achieved  13   cases  of   integration   into  employment,  with  14   contracts,   representing   52%   of   the   total.   Moreover,   9   of   the   25   women   selected   found   employment   in   the   informal   labour   market.  These  figures  are  expected  to  have  increased  by  the  time  the  programme  ends  in  March  2014.     Most  of  the  contracts  (71.43%)  were  for  part-­‐time  work,  whilst  28.57%  were  for  full-­‐time  jobs.     86%  of  the  women  that  found  work  obtained  quality  employment,  as  their  contracts  were  for  more  than   six  months  and/or  responded  to  the  professional  goal  they  had  proposed.       86%  of  contracts  were  temporary,   for   less   than  six  months.  One  contract  was  permanent  and  one   for   less  than  one  month.                       The  jobs  related  to  the  cleaning  sector  (services  to  businesses  and  individuals)  accounted  for  71.43%  of   total  contracts.  85.71%  of  the  women  who  found  work  did  so  through  the  organisation’s  mediation  and   job  listings.  12.5%  (two  women  out  of  16)  who  completed  work  practice  in  2013  later  found  work  at  the   same  company.       EDITION  4  (Annex  2)  Group  5     The  women  who  took  part  in  this  edition  began  the  process  in  September  2013  and  will  complete  it  in   August  2014.  This  report  analyses  data  from  September  to  December  2013.     Of  the  31  women  referred  to  the  programme,  25  took  part  in  the  selection  process.  Of  these,  11  women   were  not   selected  due   to   lack  of   availability,   not  having  a  work  permit,   not   speaking   the   language  or   having   little   interest   or   motivation.   Fifteen   women   were   finally   selected,   and   these   continued   the   process  actively  at  31  December  2013.                                           SECTORS   OF   EMPLOYMENT   INTEGRATION   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Services  to  companies  (cleaning)   64.29%   Services  to  individuals  (cleaning)   7.14%   Hotels   14.29%   Social  and  textile   14.28%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     32                                                         76%  of  the  women  who  took  part  in  DIR  Edition  3  had  children  or  other  people  in  their  charge.       ⎯ Actions  to  implement  the  professional  project     To  ensure   that  each  of   the  participating  women  could  develop   their  professional  projects   individually   and  at  their  own  rhythm,  a  range  of  resources  was  proposed:     -­‐ Individualised   actions:  personalised   interviews,   employability   analysis   tutorials,   comparison   of   skills  profile  with  requirements  of  the  job  established  as  the  goal,  formulating  an  action  plan  to   achieve  the  goals  established.   -­‐ Training   actions:   introductory   workshop   on   working   as   a   domestic   assistant,   food   handling   certificate,  active  job  seeking  techniques,  transversal  skills.   -­‐ Job  seeking/integration  plan  actions   Work   practice   at   companies:   at   31   December   2013,   7   of   the   15  women   taken   on   at   the   start   of   the   programme   (46.67%)   had   completed   work   practice   as   domestic   assistants   at   companies   and   were   awaiting  the  opportunity  to  fill  any  vacancies.     ⎯ Cases  of  integration  into  employment     The  women  began  the  process  in  September/October  and  at  31  December  2013  were  still  preparing  the   action  plan  for  active  job  seeking  work.  Accordingly,  none  had  yet  been  integrated  into  employment.   MAIN  COUNTRIES  OF   ORIGIN     Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   National   20%   Migrant   80%   Latin   Ecuador   36%   16%   Sub-­‐Saharan   Nigeria   24%   16%   Eastern  Europe   Bulgaria   Russia   Romania   16%   8%   4%   4%   Morocco   4%   DOCUMENTATION   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Official  Spanish  ID   20%   Community  (residence)   8%   Community  (residence  and   work)   72%   AGE  GROUPS   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Under  25  years   0%   25-­‐35  years   36%   36-­‐45  years     56%   46  -­‐65  years   8%   LEVEL  OF  STUDIES   Edition  3  -­‐  Group  4   %   Unschooled   8%   Primary     28%   Secondary   48%   University     4%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     33       OVERALL   RESULTS   OF   INTEGRATION   INTO   EMPLOYMENT   THROUGH   THE   DIR   PROGRAMME  IN  2013     Edition  2  of  the  DIR  programme  (G2  and  G3)  achieved  31  cases  of  integration  into  employment,  with  24   women   obtaining   a   total   of   31   contracts.   In   this   edition,   11  women   also   found  work   in   the   informal   employment  market.     At   31   December   2013,   DIR   Edition   3   (Annex   1)   Group   4   had   achieved   13   cases   of   integration   into   employment  involving  13  women  (52%),  with  14  contracts  (one  woman  received  two  contracts).  In  this   edition,   9  women   also   found  work   in   the   informal   employment  market.  More   contracts   and   cases   of   integration  into  employment  may  occur  before  this  edition  ends  in  March  2014.     In  DIR  edition  4  (Annex  2)  Group  5,  there  have  as  yet  been  no  cases  of  integration  into  employment,  as   the  programme  ends  on  August  2014.     In  all,  37  women  found  work,  with  45  labour  contracts  (24  women  in  Edition  2  and  13  in  Edition  3)  and   20  women  found  work   in   the   informal  employment  market.   It   should  be  noted  that   the  same  woman   may  have  worked  in  both  the  formal  and  informal  employment  markets.     This  programme  is  included  in  the  strategic  line  for  the  re-­‐employment  of  women  who  wish  to  give  up   prostitution  voluntarily  and  embark  on  a  professional  project.  The  programme  is  implemented  with  the   framework  of  a  cooperation  agreement  with  the  Surt  Private  Foundation  for  Women.           5.2.  ITI  Personal  advisory  itinerary  for  the  employment  of  women  who  have   been  engaged  in  prostitution     This  programme  is  aimed  at  women  who  have  been  engaged  in  prostitution  and  have  been  linked  to  the   formal   employment   market   during   the   last   two   years.   The   programme   fosters   employability   and   maintenance  in  the  employment  market  by  improving  skills  and  reducing  the  impact  of  the  recession  on   professional  projects.     The   itinerary  was  provided  for  a  total  of  23  women,  divided   into  two  groups:   the  first  group  (G1)  was   formed   by   11   women   who   had   recently   joined   the   ITI   programme,   referred   by   the   network   of   organisations,  whilst   the  second   (G2)  was   formed  by  a   total  of  12  women,  9  of  whom  came   from  the   2012-­‐2013  DIR  programme  and  3  from  previous  editions  of  the  DIR  programme.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     34                                 Data  from  the  G1  +  G2  profile     Of  the  total  number  of  women   in  groups  G1  and  G2  (23  women),  78.27%  (18  women)  were  migrants,   mostly   of   Latin   American   origin   (44.44%)   and   mainly   from   Colombia   and   Ecuador.   The   next   largest   groups  were  women  from  Nigeria  (33.33%)  and  the  Eastern  European  countries  (22.22%).  The  remaining   21.74%  (five  women)  were  Spanish  nationals.                           47.83%  of  the  participants  had  completed  secondary  studies,  39.13%  primary  studies  and  13.04%  higher   studies  (one  Spanish  national  had  a  university  degree  and  two  migrant  women  had  university  diplomas   from  their  countries  of  origin).     65.22%  of  the  women  had  children,  living  with  them  in  80%  of  cases  and  with  relatives  in  the  country  of   origin  in  the  remaining  20%.  Women  without  family  members  under  their  charge  accounted  for  34.78%   of  the  total.     65.22%  of  the  women  taking  part  in  the  ITI  programme  were  unemployed,  whilst  34.78%  were  working   at  the  time  of  joining  the  programme.  17.40%  of  the  women  (four)  received  some  kind  of  benefit  during   the  months  that  they  were  following  the  programme.       The  main  factors  of  vulnerability  were:  coverage  of  basic  needs  such  as  food,  clothes,  etc.  (73.91%),  lack   of  Spanish  language  skills  (60.87%),  need  for  legal  advice  (56.52%),  housing  instability  (39.13%)  and  lack   of  technical  skills  to  achieve  employment  goals  (34.78%).   ITI  GROUPS  2012-­‐2013   Number  of   women   participating   G1  Women  newly  arrived   11   G2  Women  from  DIR     12   2012-­‐2013  Edition     9   Previous  editions   3      TOTAL  WOMEN  (G1  and  G2)   23   AGE  GROUPS     Total  (G1  +  G2)   %   2012   Total  (G1  +  G2)   %   2013   Under  25  years   0%   0%   26-­‐35  years   47.83%   48%   36-­‐45  years     21.74%   28%   46-­‐65  years   17.39%   24%   Over  55  years   13.04%   0%   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     35       Actions  implemented     According  to  the  needs  and  potential  of  each  woman,  both  group  and  individual  work  was  conducted  on   the  content  of  all  actions:     -­‐ Change   processes   to   be   implemented   during   the   course   of   the   itinerary   (expectations,   real   possibilities  of  the  project,  tutorial  relation).   -­‐ Approach   to   the   different   spheres   of   life:   health,   personal   space,   relationships,   training   and   work  (cornerstone),  challenges  and  proposals  for  improvement.   -­‐ Definition   and   implementation  of   the  professional   project:   approximation   to   the   employment   market  and  the  economic  context,  analysis  of  employability,  comparison  of  skills  profile  with  the   requirements  of  the  job  chosen,  establishment  of  an  action  plan  to  achieve  the  challenges  set,   implementation  of  the  professional  project.   -­‐ Guidance   for   training,   job   seeking   skills,   active   job   searching,   actions   linked   to   the   women’s   needs  in  life  (legal  advice,  duty  of  care).   -­‐ Technical   training  with  work  practice:   two  women  completed  work  practice  as  chambermaids,   five  as  kitchen  assistants  and  one  as  a  sales  assistant.   -­‐ Instrumental  training:  literacy  and  basic  computer  skills,  Language  Normalisation  Centre.     Integration  into  training     There   were   a   total   of   39   cases   of   integration   into   training,   20   internal   to   the   organisation   and   19   external:     -­‐ 20  cases  of  internal  integration  into  training:   -­‐ 14  women  in  the  field  of  computer  studies:  3  in  computer  literacy,  4  in  basic  computer   skills  and  7  linked  to  job  seeking.   -­‐ 4  women  in  the  work  of  a  kitchen  assistant.   -­‐ 1  woman  in  the  work  of  a  chambermaid.   -­‐ 1  woman  in  the  work  of  a  sales  assistant.     -­‐ 19  cases  of  external  integration  into  training:   -­‐ 2  women  in  the  field  of  computer  studies.     -­‐ 7  women  in  languages:  4  in  Catalan  and  3  in  English.   -­‐ 8  women  in  food  handling.   -­‐ 1  woman  in  higher  training  (CFGS)  in  image  diagnosis.     -­‐ 1  woman  in  the  work  of  a  chambermaid.   Integration  into  employment     Seventeen   women   were   integrated   into   employment,   with   twenty-­‐seven   contracts   in   the   hotel,   cleaning,   sales,   kitchen   assistant,   domestic   service   and   assistant   librarian   trades.   Moreover,   eight   women  found  work  in  the  informal  employment  market.  It  happens  that  one  woman  found  work  in  both   the  formal  and  informal  employment  markets.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     36       Work  practice  at  companies  and  integration  into  employment     Online  technical  training  related  to  obtaining  food  handling  certificates  was  provided  in  order  to  enable   the  women  to  meet  different  profiles  that  require  this  qualification,  such  as  the  jobs  of  kitchen  assistant,   product  promoter  and  waitress.       Work  practice  processes  help  participants  to  develop  technical  and  transversal  skills  (situation  in  the  real   work   setting)   and   to   improve   their   technical   profiles,   accrediting   skills.   Moreover,   this   activity   also   enables   participants   to   come   into   direct   contact   with   companies   as   a   gateway   to   integration   Into   employment.     WORK  PRACTICE   WOMEN    PARTICIPATING   INSERTIONS     Kitchen  assistant   5   1  kitchen  assistant  1  cleaner   Chambermaid   2   1  person  integrated10   Sales  manager   1   0  people  integrated       This  programme  is  included  in  the  strategic  line  for  the  re-­‐employment  of  women  who  wish  to  give  up   prostitution  voluntarily  and  to  embark  on  a  professional  project.  In  this  case,  a  cooperation  agreement   with  the  Surt  Private  Foundation  for  Women  was  established.           5.3.  ACCIÓ  Programme  of  comprehensive  intervention  for  transsexual  people   linked  to  prostitution  milieus  in  the  city  of  Barcelona     The  ACCIÓ  (“ACTION”)  programme  is  aimed  at  transsexual  people  who  are  engaged  in  prostitution  and   have  a  clear  motivation  to  join  the  formal  employment  market,  have  regularised  documentation  in  the   case  of  migrants  and  have  a  personal  situation  and  a  minimum  level  of  Spanish/Catalan  language  skills   that  enable  them  to  follow  a  training  process.     The   programme   pursues   the   objective   of   developing   personal   itineraries   for   social   and   employment   integration,   taking   into   account   the   specific   experiences   of   transsexual   people,   and   of   addressing   instances   of   discrimination   suffered   and   experienced,   as   well   as   the   reluctance   of   companies   and   possible  employers.  The  programme  focuses  on  training  and  empowering  individuals,  as  well  as  on  the   world  of  business,  promoting  inclusion  and  non-­‐discrimination.       The   programme   was   launched   on   1   January   2012   within   the   framework   of   the   new   government   measure  and  ended  on  30  April  2013.  A  second  edition  has  now  been  launched  and  will  run  from  1  July   2013  to  30  June  2014.       The  data  collected  in  this  report  correspond  to  the  second  edition,  up  to  31  December  2013.                                                                                                                   10  One  of  the  women  left  the  job  due  to  personal  difficulties  and  the  integration  experience  therefore  lasted  less  than  a  month.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     37       Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  women  participating     A   total   of   31   women   took   part,   26   of   them   for   the   first   time   and   5   from   the   first   edition   of   the   programme.       50%  of   the   participants   received   no   kind   of   benefit,   20%   the  minimum   income   for   integration   (RMI),   20%  non-­‐contributory  pensions  and  10%  benefits  from  the  Employment  Service  of  Catalonia  (SOC).       48.38%   had   completed   primary   education,   48.38%   had   completed   secondary   education   and   the   remaining  3.22%  had  completed  university  studies.         NATIONALITY   %   Spanish   45   Latin  America   48   Ecuador   20   Colombia   16   Brazil   3   Panama   3   Uruguay   3   Morocco   7     Personal  itineraries     The  31  women  selected  followed  three  itineraries  according  to  their  specific  needs:     -­‐   21   (67.74%)   followed   a   training   itinerary   focused   on   vocational   training   and   mentoring   processes  with  the  work  practice  derived  from  these  processes.     -­‐  5  (16.13%)  followed  an  itinerary  in  which  work  mainly  focused  on  integration,  whilst  training   and  mentoring  were  also  provided.     -­‐  5  (16.13%)  followed  social   itineraries  that   involved  completing   in-­‐depth  work  (personal  development   and  empowerment)  before  they  could  access  any  kind  of  training  or  integration  activity.     In  all,  15  people  took  part   in  the  vocational  training  activities  (the  same  woman  could  take  more  than   one  course).     Of  the  12  people  who  enrolled   in  the  bar  waitress  course,  11  completed  their   training  and  8  (66.66%)   successfully  achieved  the  skills  needed  to  work  in  the  sector.       Fifteen   participants   were   selected   for   the   chambermaid   course,   some   of   them   coming   from   the   bar   waitress  course.  Of  these  15  persons,  12  (80%)  successfully  completed  the  training  process.      The   module   on   training   in   social   and   employment   skills   was   aimed   at   those   participants   with   shortcomings   in   transversal   skills   that  made   the   integration  process  more  difficult.   Seven  people   took   part  in  this  module,  and  all  completed  it  successfully.     AGE  GROUPS   %   Under  25  years   -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐   26-­‐35  years   22.58   36-­‐45  years     35.48   46-­‐55  years   32.26   Over  56  years   9.68   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     38       Besides  training  actions,  the  programme  also  included  a  total  of  eight  transversal  activities  to  work  on   personal   empowerment   and  ways   of   approaching   the   employment  market.   The  women   took   part   in   several   awareness-­‐raising   activities   focused  on   violence   against  women  and   gender   violence,   talks   on   transphobic  attacks  (given  by  the  Catalan  Police),  educational  trips  and  visits  to  companies  and  training   and  leisure  centres  (Ciutadella  Park,  the  gazebo  dedicated  to  the  transsexual  Sònia).  There  were  a  total   of  99  participations  by  58  different  people.     Work   practice   was   offered   at   companies   related   to   the   technical   and   professional   training   provided.   Four  of  the  people  proposed  to  companies  completed  work  practice  (six  work  practice  contracts  were   signed,   as   one   woman   completed   two   itineraries;   this   woman   and   one   other   completed   the   work   practice  successfully).       Interventions  in  the  business  system     Contacts  were  established  with  13  companies,  all  of  which  were  receptive  to  future  cooperation  (visits   to  their  facilities,  taking  on  students  for  work  practice,  training  sessions  or  possible  recruitments).  Joint   actions  were  carried  out  with  many  of  these  companies,  such  as  the  placement  of  students  for  a  total  of   six  work  practice  experiences,  informative  talks  and  introductory  visits  to  the  world  of  employment.     Integration  into  employment     As  regards  the  second  edition  of  the  programme  (which  ends  on  30  June  2014),  at  31  December  2013   one  woman  had   achieved   integration   into   the  hairdressing   sector  with   a   substitution   contract   due   to   maternity  leave.  It  is  hoped  that  more  cases  of  integration  into  employment  may  occur  over  the  course   of  2014.11     At   the   same   time,   work   with   all   participants   also   focused   on   improving   their   communication   and   language   skills,   as   well   as   their   personal   responsibility   for   taking   care   of   their   health.   Given   the   importance  of  health  issues  to  this  group,  links  are  maintained  with  the  Catsalut  Transit  Service,  which   provides   free   health   information   and   advice   to   transsexual   people.   A   total   of   eight   users   (26%)   have   been  referred  to  this  service.       This   programme   is   implemented   under   the   municipal   strategic   line   for   the   re-­‐employment   of   transsexual  women  who  wish  to  give  up  prostitution  voluntarily  and  embark  on  their  own  professional   projects.  In  this  case,  Barcelona  City  Council  established  a  cooperation  agreement  with  the  APIP-­‐ACAM   (Association  for  Professional  Promotion  and  Integration)  Foundation.                                                                                                                     11  During  the  closing  stage  of  the  first  edition  of  the  programme,  from  1  January  to  30  April  2013,  six  people  were  integrated   into  the  formal  employment  market,  with  eight  contracts.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     39       5.4.  Training,  employment  and  social  integration  programme  with  training  and   employment  itineraries             The   objective   of   the   social   and   employment   training   programme   is   to   improve   the   quality   of   life   of   people   engaged   in   prostitution   by   providing   customised   training   and   employment   integration   itineraries.   An   important   characteristic   of   the   programme   is   its   flexibility   and   ability   to   adapt   to   the   changing   needs   of  women,   and   to   accept   their   inclusion   at   any   time   during   the   year.  Moreover,   the   initiative  is  linked  to  benefits,  enabling  participation  in  the  activity  to  be  monitored.  The  training  process   for   each   woman   may   be   longer   or   shorter   depending   on   their   knowledge   and   experience   prior   to   entering  the  programme.  A  recently  arrived  migrant  woman  needs  a  minimum  period  of   two  years   to   complete  the  process.     In  2013,  220  women  received  this  assistance,  embarking  on  training  itineraries  (180)  and/or  integration   into  employment  itineraries  (82).     Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  women  assisted     By   nationality,   amongst   the   220   women   who   received   assistance,   the   largest   group   were   those   of   Nigerian   origin   (75%,   compared   to   70%   in   2012),   followed  by   those   of   Romanian  origin   (11.8%)   Latin   women  (7.72%),  women  of  Moroccan  origin  (3.18%)  and  Spanish  nationals  (2.27%).     Training  activities       El  2013,  180  women  took  part   in  different   training   itineraries  and  activities,  a  41.73%   increase  on   the   previous  year.       TRAINING  ACTIVITY     (one  single  woman  may  have   attended  more  than  one  workshop)   2012   2012   2013   2013   WOMEN   Number  of  workshops   WOMEN   Number  of   workshops   Spanish  and  Catalan  classes12   68  women    different  levels     100  women   different  levels     Workshops  on  domestic   service  and  caring  for  elderly   people13   20  women   2  workshops   19  women   2  courses  (70  +  90  hrs)   Chambermaid  course14   (School  of  Tourism)   15  women   1  course   14  women   1  course   (177  hrs)   Employment  guidance   workshops     11  women   8  workshops   28  women   11  sessions   5  workshops   Workshops  on  domestic   economy     25  women   2  workshops   10  women   1  workshop   Workshops  on  basic  health   and  child  nutrition     16  women   2  workshops   4  women   3  workshops                                                                                                                     12   The   introductory   workshops   were   included   in   the   Spanish   classes.   Four   such  workshops   were   organised,   for   twenty-­‐two   women.  Some  of   the   language   learning  sessions  were  also  devoted   to  coaching   for   job   interviews,   in  which  six  women  took   part.     13  In  2013,  this  data  was  broken  down  into  a  course  for  caring  for  elderly  people,  cleaning,  cooking  and  ironing,  and  a  course  in   cooking  for  elderly  people.     14    This  course,  given  by  the  School  of  Tourism,  had  a  70%  success  rate  in  women  integrated  into  employment  over  the  year.  It   should  be  noted  that  the  course  is  taken  by  users  with  higher  levels  of  pre-­‐employment  training  and  language  skills.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     40       With  regard  to  variations  in  the  data,  it  should  be  noted  that  the  programme  made  a  larger  investment   in  providing  pre-­‐employment  training  for  the  women  who  received  assistance,  increasing  the  number  of   sessions   in   such  subjects  as   languages   (Spanish  and  Catalan)  and   the  differentiating   features  between   the  different  cultures   in  order   to  establish   the  best  possible  conditions   for  participants   to  successfully   start  out  on  a  training  and  employment  integration  itinerary.  This   led  to  more  efficient  use  of  external   training   facilities   and   an   increase   in   referrals   to   other   training   resources   during   the   second   semester   (three  women  to  the  APIP  Foundation,  two  to  the  School  of  Tourism  and  three  to  IMPULSEM).     In   2013,   other   training   activities   organised   included   three   introductory   sessions   to   the   world   of   schooling  (twenty-­‐three  women),  one  workshop  on  legal  issues  (seven  women),  one  session  discussing   Catalonia   and  Nigeria   (five  women)   and   one  workshop   devoted   to   actively   seeking  work   in   domestic   service  (six  women).     Referrals  from  the  training  itinerary  to  external  resources       Referrals   were   made   to   external   resources,   but   educational   monitoring   was   maintained   in   order   to   provide  the  women  with  support  and  ensure  that  the  objectives  established  were  successfully  achieved:       TRAINING  RESOURCE   (the  same  woman  may  have  taken  more  than  one  course  or  workshop)   2012   2013   Number  of   women   Number  of   women   ITI  and  DIR-­‐TS  (ABITS  Agency  training  itineraries)     12   6   “Dona  Impuls”-­‐Barcelona  Activa  (ABITS)   -­‐-­‐-­‐   8   Courses  in  working  as  a  chambermaid,  laundry  and  ironing   (APIP)   6   3   Rehabilitation  and  cleaning  of  apartments  (Impulsem)   -­‐-­‐-­‐   3   Sales  and  restocking  assistant  (School  of  Tourism)     -­‐-­‐-­‐   2   Course  in  caring  for  dependent  people  (Migraestudio)   4   2   Catalan  and/or  Spanish  language  course   -­‐-­‐-­‐   25   Digital  literacy     -­‐-­‐-­‐   2   Sexual  health,  basic  health  and  nutrition  (Doctors  of  the   World)   -­‐-­‐-­‐   30   Workshop  on  health  diagnosis  (Tot  Raval)   -­‐-­‐-­‐   6   Talk  on  World  Health  Day  (HIV)  UMTSI   -­‐-­‐-­‐   6   Kitchen  assistant  course       3   -­‐-­‐-­‐   Bar  staff  assistant  course   3   -­‐-­‐-­‐   Social  and  health  care  course       2   -­‐-­‐-­‐   TOTAL  (the  same  woman  may  have  completed  more  than  one   course)   30   93     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     41       Cases  of  integration  into  employment     A  survey  of  companies  was  carried  out  that  resulted  in  17  women  being  given  jobs.  The  recession  and   the   economic   situation   have   caused   a   reduction   in   the   number   of  women   employed   to   take   care   of   dependent  persons  in  private  homes.  Most  of  the  contracts  were  part-­‐time  and  temporary.  Moreover,   12  women  found  work  in  the  informal  employment  market.  It  so  happened  that  one  woman  worked  in   both  the  formal  and  informal  employment  markets.                                               Under  the  line  established  by  the  ABITS  Agency  to  provide  social  and  employment  training  to   improve   the   quality   of   life   of   women   who   wish   to   give   up   prostitution,   Barcelona   City   Council   established   a   cooperation   agreement   with   the   congregation   of   Oblate   Sisters   of   the   Holy   Redeemer,   El   Lloc   de   la   Dona,  in  order  to  implement  this  programme.         SECTOR     2012   2013   Number  of   contracts   Number  of   contracts   Kitchen  assistant   0  contracts   1   Industrial/hotel  cleaning     26   13   Care  for  elderly  people   5   0  contracts   Care  for  elderly  people  with  domestic  service   1   3   TOTAL   32   17   ORIGIN  OF  WOMEN  HIRED   2012   2013   %     %   Sub-­‐Saharan  Africa   42   64.7   Latin  America   39   23.5   Eastern  Europe  (Romania)   16   5.8   Morocco     3   5.8   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     42       5.5.  The  “Dona  Impuls”  Social  and  Employment  Integration  Programme       The   ABITS   Agency   commissioned   Barcelona   Activa   to   draw   up   a   programme   aimed   at   Sub-­‐Saharan   women  who  were  engaged  or  had  been  engaged   in  prostitution  and   sought  employment  alternatives   and  were  available  and  motivated  to  undertake  a  social  and  employment  itinerary.     The   result   was   a   tailor-­‐made   programme   that   gave   the   women   access   to   training,   guidance   and   accompaniment   resources   for   integration   in   a   series   of   phases:   introduction   to   the   programme,   professional   guidance,   acquisition   of   transversal   skills,   vocational   training   and   accompaniment   for   integration.   The   programme   began   in   November   2012,   in   the   framework   of   the   new   government   measure,  and  ended  in  July  2013.  A  total  of  43  women  took  part  in  the  initiative.   Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  women  provided  with  assistance     The   programme   was   aimed   at   Sub-­‐Saharan   women,   90.7%   of   whom   were   from   Nigeria.   The   four   remaining  users  were  from  Equatorial  Guinea,  Togo,  Ghana  and  Sierra  Leone.     By   age,   the   largest   group  were  women   aged   26-­‐35   years   (60.46%),   followed   by   the   36-­‐45   age   group   (25.58%),  those  aged  18-­‐25  years  (11.62%)  and,  finally,  the  46-­‐55  age  group  (2.32%).     Most   of   the  women   (62.79%)  were   in   a   regularised   administrative   situation   and   53.48%  had   children   living  with  them  in  their  charge,  generally  in  single-­‐parent  families.     Programme  phases     PHASE  1.  introduction   Over  the  first   two  months  of   the  programme  (2012),  different  organisations  referred  40  women  to   the   initiative,   24   of  whom   (60%)   attended   the   4   information   sessions   that  were   held.   In   total,   31   women  were   invited  to   individual   introductory   interviews,  with  an  attendance  rate  of  87%.  Finally,   27  joined  the  programme  in  the  introductory  phase.       PHASE  2.  Professional  guidance  and  job  seeking  techniques     The   possibility   of  more  women  entering   the   programme   in   the   other   phases  was   left   open   and,   as   a   result,  16  more  users  later  joined  the  initiative.     Twenty-­‐three   women   took   part   in   five   two-­‐hour   workshops   (there   were   two   editions   of   each   workshop,   one   for   each   group   of   women)   on:   self-­‐awareness,   CV   and   letter   of   introduction,   job   search  channels,  job  interview  and  employment  issues.       After   the   introductory  phase  and   in  a  cross-­‐cutting  way   to   the   rest  of   the  programme,   the  women   received   individual   tutorials   in   which   the   Itineraries   that   were   most   appropriate   for   each   were   agreed  on  a  one-­‐to-­‐one  basis  .  A  total  of  82  guidance  tutorials  were  given,  with  the  participation  of   26  different  women.     PHASE  3.  Acquisition  of  transversal  skills   A   total   of   17   women   were   referred   to   different   partner   organisations   in   order   to   improve   their   Spanish   language   skills.   Five   of   these   women   also   requested   and   completed   Catalan   language   training.       Seventeen   women   took   part   in   the   two   modules   devoted   to   digital   literacy,   whilst   18   women   attended  two  yoga  modules.     PHASE  4.  Training     Two  training  Itineraries  were  established  to  enable  users  to  acquire  the  technical  skills  necessary  in   the  posts  of  kitchen  assistant  and  chambermaid.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     43         Twenty-­‐six  women   (60.45%)   enrolled   for   these   Itineraries.   To   enable   them   to   attend   this   training,   considerable  efforts  were  made  to  liaise  with  the  referring  organisations  in  order  to  detect  needs  and   provide  resources  for  the  care  of  their  children  (food  subsidies,  etc.).     The  two  Itineraries  comprised  a  first  part  of  200  hours  devoted  to  theory  and  practice  and  a  second   part  consisting  of  75  hours’  work  practice:     -­‐  Kitchen  assistant   itinerary:  14  women  (53.84%)  began  the  training,  and  4  (15.38%)  completed  the   work  practice,  whilst  5  (19.23%)  dropped  out.     -­‐   Work   as   a   chambermaid:   12   women   (46.15%)   began   the   training,   6   (23%)   completed   the   work   practice  and  four  (15.38%)  dropped  out.         PHASE  5.  Accompaniment  for  integration   A   group   of   13   women   was   formed   to   work   on   active   job   seeking   using   the   new   technologies.   Moreover,  29  women  attended  96  tutorials  to  monitor  their  progress  in  the  training  and  integration   itinerary.       2013           PHASES     ACTIVITIES   (A  single  women  may   have  attended  more  than   one  workshop)     Number   of  actions   Number  of   participants   PHASE  1   Information  sessions     4   24     Interviews     43   43   PHASE  2   Professional  guidance  modules   Self-­‐knowledge   2   23       Curriculum   2   20       Job  search  channels   2   18       Interview   2   18       Employment  issues   2   20     Tutorials     82   26   PHASE  3   Language   Spanish   -­‐   17       Catalan   -­‐   5     Personal   skills  (yoga)     2   18     Digital  literacy     2   17   PHASE  4   Professional  skills   Kitchen  assistant   1   12       Chambermaid  course   1   14     Integration  and  guidance  itinerary     -­‐   15     Key  skills     2   19   PHASE  5   Job  search     1   13     Monitoring  tutorials     96   29   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     44       Integration  into  employment     A  total  of  11  women  found  work,  10  in  the  formal  employment  market  in  hotels  and  tourism,  cleaning   or  caring  for  elderly  people  and  1  woman  in  the  informal  employment  market.         This   programme   is   included   in   the   strategic   line  for  the  re-­‐employment  of   women   who   wish   to   give   up   prostitution   voluntarily   and  embark  on   a   professional   project.   In   this   case,   Barcelona  Activa  was   commissioned   to   manage  the  programme.     5.6.  Special  accompaniment  mechanism  for  the  integration  into  the  employment   market  and  the  social  fabric  of  women  engaged  in  prostitution  who  seek   employment  alternatives       The  accompaniment  programme  is  aimed  at  women  whose  administration  situation  is  either  regular  or   can  be   regularised   (in  process  or   sufficient   years’   residence   in   the   country   to  prove   settlement),  with   previous   work   experience   or   that   have   acquired   good   employment   habits   (hygiene,   punctuality,   responsibility,  social  relations,  etc.)  through  training  courses.  These  are  women  who  are  in  structural  or   temporary   situations   of   disorientation   that   require   accompaniment   and   a   personalised   approach   in   order  to  achieve  alternatives  for  access  to  the  employment  market.     In   2013,   a   total   of   84   women   were   provided   with   this   assistance,   and   24   of   whom   continued   the   process,  which  began  in  2012.  From  January  to  June  2013,  25  women  were  referred  to  this  mechanism   and,  from  July  to  December,  a  further  35.       Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  participating  women     44.05%  of   the  women  who  participated  had  completed  secondary  education,  34.52%  had  received  no   education  or  had  completed  only  primary  studies  and  the  remaining  21.43%  had  completed  secondary   education  with  additional  vocational  training.                                               89.28%  were  in  a  regularised  administrative  situation.                                 OCCUPATIONS   2013   Number  of  contracts   Chambermaids   5   Cleaning   3   Caring  for  elderly  people   2   TOTAL   10   AGE  GROUPS   2012  %   2013   %   Under  25  years   -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐   13.09   26-­‐35  years   34.6   27.38   36-­‐45  years      46.2   39.29   46-­‐65  years   19.2   20.24   ORIGIN   2012   %   2013   %   Spain   25   17.86   Africa   27   38.09   Nigeria   18   30.95   Latin  America   32   27.38   Ecuador   14   10.71   Eastern  Europe   15   16.67   Romania   11   9.52   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     45       Integration  into  training     Twenty-­‐one  women   received   training   in   various   fields.   The   total   number   of   training   activities  was   23   (the  same  woman  may  have  taken  part  in  more  than  one  training  activity):       -­‐  Computer  studies  (one  woman)   -­‐  DIR  (six  women)   -­‐  “Dona  Impuls”  (five  women)   -­‐  ITI  (two  women)   -­‐  Chambermaid  (three  women)   -­‐  Food  handling  (one  woman)   -­‐  Kitchen  (one  woman)   -­‐  Tattooing  (one  woman)   -­‐  Home  carer  (one  woman)   -­‐  Seamstress  (one  woman)   -­‐  Spanish/literacy  (one  woman)     Integration  into  employment     A  total  of  22  women  were  integrated  into  the  formal  employment  market  through  33  contracts   in  the   following  sectors:  14  in  cleaning  companies,  9  in  hotels,  4  in  geriatric  home  assistance,  3  in  commerce,  1   in  domestic   service,  1  at  a  nursing  home  for   the  elderly  and  1   in  beauty.  Moreover,  12  women  found   work   in  the   informal  employment  market.   It  happens  that  one  woman  found  work   in  both  the  formal   and  informal  employment  markets.     The  women  were  monitored  both  during  the  training  process  and  in  the  employment  process.     Transversal  actions  (throughout  the  process)     -­‐ 40   women   received   assistance   and   support   at   times   of   crisis   caused   by   personal   and   professional  stress.     -­‐ 17  women  received  legal  advice  on  employment  and  immigration  issues.     -­‐ 8  women  worked  on  urban  mobility.     -­‐ 26   women   who   were   found   to   have   deficiencies   in   language   skills   despite   having   taken   Spanish/Catalan  courses  or  who  had  not  achieved  the  basic  level  to  sustain  integration  worked   to   alleviate   the   constraints   on   their   employability.   These   women   were   referred   to   initiatives   aimed  at  improving  these  areas  (language  proficiency  certificate,  etc.).     This  programme  is  included  in  the  strategic  line  for  the  re-­‐employment  of  women  who  wish  to  give  up   prostitution   voluntarily   and   embark   on   a   professional   project.   In   this   case,   the   programme   was   implemented  under  an  agreement  established  with  the  social  and  employment  integration  coordination   body  Anem  per  feina.                     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     46       5.7.  Enfilant  l’Agulla  (“Threading  the  Needle”)  innovation  programme     The  objective  of  this  programme  of  training  in  sewing,  aimed  for  the  most  part  at  Nigerian  women,  is  to   equip   participants  with   the   level   of   professionalism   required   for   clothes   production.   To   this   end,   the   organisation  has  its  own  garment-­‐making  and  fashion  and  home  accessory  production  workshop,  selling   produce  under  the  Dona  Kolors  social  brand.  Participants  are  also  provided  with  the  necessary  tools  to   become  self-­‐employed  in  the  sector.     Thirty-­‐eight  women   received   this   training   as   seamstresses,  which  was  divided   into   three   levels:   initial   phase  (basic  sewing  skills);  second  phase  (basic  sewing);  and  third  phase  (advanced  sewing).  The  process   lasted  approximately  one  year,  with  a  total  of  420  hours  of  training.     The   seven  women  who   completed   the   three   phases   completed  work   practice   at   different   companies   and  received  a  semi-­‐professional  sewing  machine  in  order  to  encourage  them  to  become  self-­‐employed.     TRAINING  IN  SEWING   Duration  of  training   Number  of  women   INITIAL  PHASE     10  hours  per  week   19     SECOND  PHASE   10  hours  per  week   6   THIRD  PHASE   10  hours  per  week   10   Complementary  knitting   training  workshop     10  hours  per  week   4   WORK  PRACTICE   40  hours   7     The   training   was   complemented   by   eight   two-­‐hour   sessions   focusing   on   job   skills   and   two   on   entrepreneurship,  with   the  participation  of  18  women.  One   single  woman  could  participate   in  one  or   more  training  phases  of  training  as  well  as  one  or  more  of  these  sessions.     Dona  Kolors  products  are  available  at  17  outlets  in  Catalonia  and  the  rest  of  Spain  (Natura  shop  chain,   museum   gift   shops,   sustainable   clothes   stores,   boutiques   in   tourist   areas),   from   its   own   online   store   (www.donakolors.cat)  and  from  an  online  store  in  Holland.  These  channels  increase  market  options  by   240%  compared  to  the  previous  year,  when  there  were  just  five  outlets  for  the  product.     The  initiative  embodies  an  innovative  social  enterprise  programme  established  specifically  to  create  new   employment   options.   The   women   attend   monthly   tutorials,   assessment   interviews   with   programme   managers  and  technical  evaluation  meetings,  as  well  as  receiving  a  full  assessment  at  the  end  of  the  year.     Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  women  provided  with  assistance     By   nationality,   the   largest   group   are  women   of   Nigerian   origin   (78.94%),   followed   by   Latin   American   women  (15.78%).  Those  from  Romania  and  Morocco  account  for  2.63%  of  the  total.                     AGE  OF  THE  WOMEN   Number  of  women   26-­‐35  years   26   36-­‐45  years   10   18-­‐  25  years   2   Total   38   ORIGIN  OF  WOMEN   EMPLOYED   Number  of   women   Sub-­‐Saharan  Africa   30   Latin  America   6   Eastern  Europe  (Romania)   1   Morocco     1   Total   38   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     47       Integration  into  employment     In   2013,   three   women  were   integrated   into   the   formal   employment  market:   two   were   hired   by   the   workshop   itself  and  one  to  work   in  a  shop,  engaged   in  making  alterations   to  clothing.  Moreover,   four   more  women  became  self-­‐employed  in  the  informal  market.     This   programme   forms   part   of   the   strategic   line   established   by   the   Council   Department   for   the   employment  and  social   integration  of  women  engaged   in  prostitution   through  an  agreement  with   the   Enfilant  l’Agulla  Association.     5.8.  Rosas  Crafts  Programme  of  Training  in  Sewing     This  programme,  aimed  at  women  in  situations  of  vulnerability  (whether  because  they  had  engaged  in   prostitution,   been   victims   of   human   trafficking   for   the   purpose   of   exploitation   or   formed   part   of   vulnerable   groups)   and   have   entered   re-­‐employment   programmes   implemented   by   Barcelona   City   Council  was  launched  on  1  October  2013.  Its  purpose  is  to  provide  participants  with  training  in  sewing   and   to  enable   them  to  achieve  both   the   technical   skills  and   the  entrepreneurial   attitude  necessary   to   enter  into  a  process  of  employment  adaptation.   A  total  of  nine  women  took  part   in  this   initiative,  four  from  the  DIR  programme  and  two  from  the  RAI   programme.   The   three   remaining   women   were   referred   by   SASPI,   the   Itinerant   Population   Social   Assistance  Service.  This  report  contains  details  about  the  six  women  referred  by  the  two  ABITS  Agency   programmes  (DIR  and  RAI).   Sociodemographic  profile  of  the  women  provided  with  assistance     One  woman  was  of  Spanish  origin,  whilst  the  five  remaining  participants  were  originally  from  Romania,   Ecuador,  Senegal,  Nigeria  and  Guinea  respectively.  By  age,  two  women  were  between  26  and  35  years   old,  two  more  between  46  and  55  years,  one  was  under  25  years  and  one  was  between  36  and  45  years.   In   terms   of   level   of   studies,   three  women   had   completed   primary   school,   two   had   secondary   school   studies  and  one  had  completed  higher  studies.  Two  of  the  women  had  children  in  their  charge.   Integration  into  training     The  programme  was  divided  into  three  modules:   - Module   1.   Beginner’s   level:   60   hours.   From   1   October   to   5   December   2013.   All   six   women   completed  this  module.   - Module  2.  Intermediate  level:  60  hours.  From  14  January  to  20  March  2014.  This  module  has  still   to  begin.   - Module   3.   Specialisation   level:   36   hours.   6-­‐22  May   2014   (includes   coaching   and   professional   outings).  This  module  has  still  to  begin.   Integration  into  employment     In   October   2013,   thanks   to   her   participation   in   the   programme,   one   woman   was   integrated   into   employment   with   a   full-­‐time   contract   (this   integration   is   also   credited   in   the   report   on   the   DIR   programme).   More   cases   of   integration   are   expected   under   this   programme,   which   ends   on   31   July   2014.   This  programme  is  included  in  the  strategic  line  for  the  re-­‐employment  of  women  who  wish  to  give  up   prostitution  voluntarily  and  embark  on  a  professional  project.  The  programme  is  implemented  under  a   cooperation  agreement  with  the  firm  of  José  Rosas  Taberner,  SA.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     48       6.  Services  aimed  at  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the   purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       6.1.  Approach  by  the  Socio-­‐Educational  Assistance  Service  to  cases  of  women   victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     Concepts       People  trafficking   Or   the   illegal   traffic   in   migrants.   Its   purpose   is   to   enable   the   entry   of   people   into   the   country   of   destination  illegally,  in  exchange  for  money.  It  is  a  transnational  practice.     Trafficking  in  persons15   “Trafficking   in   persons"   means   “the   recruitment,   transportation,   transfer,   harbouring   or   receipt   of   persons,  by  means  of   the   threat  or  use  of   force  or  other   forms  of  coercion,  of  abduction,  of   fraud,  of   deception,   of   the   abuse   of   power   or   of   a   position   of   vulnerability   or   of   the   giving   or   receiving   of   payments  or  benefits   to  achieve   the   consent  of   a  person  having   control  over  another  person,   for   the   purpose  of  exploitation.  Exploitation  shall  include,  at  a  minimum,  the  exploitation  of  the  prostitution  of   others   or   other   forms   of   sexual   exploitation,   forced   labour   or   services,   slavery   or   practices   similar   to   slavery,  servitude  or  the  removal  of  organs”.  Cross-­‐border  transfer  is  not  a  necessary  condition.     Characteristic  that  condition  intervention  in  these  cases         ⎯ The  women   show  a   lack  of   self-­‐identification  of   themselves  as   victims,   and   can  even   come   to   consider  the  situation  of  violence  to  which  they  are  subjected  as  normal.     ⎯ There  is  often  a  family  or  romantic  relationship  with  the  person  who  engages  in  the  exploitation,   and  this  hinders  the  identification  process.   ⎯ The  women’s  social  and  relational  networks  are  scant  or  non-­‐existent.   ⎯ Most   of   the   women   are   afraid   to   trust   professionals   and   law   enforcement   bodies,   and   the   protection  that  they  can  be  given   if  they  make  an  official  report  of  the  situation   in  which  they   find  themselves.   ⎯ There  is  a  certain  lack  of  knowledge  about  their  surroundings,  as  well  as  a  lack  of  specialisation   in   services   and   social   workers   (both   formal   and   informal)   which   hinders   the   detection   and   accompaniment  of  women  who  are  victims  of  trafficking  in  persons.   ⎯ The  coercion  and  threats  employed  by  the  networks  of  exploitation  largely  prevent  the  victims   from   reporting   their   situation.   These   psychological   and/or   physical   threats  may   concern   their   families   or   close   acquaintances,   in   Barcelona   or   in   their   countries   of   origin,   and   are   used   by   those  who  exploit  them  to  stop  them  from  complaining  to  the  authorities.     ⎯ The  women  are  unaware  of   the   legal   framework   and   the  protection   that  may  be   available   to   them  (as  victims  of  one  or  more  crimes)  and  the  welfare  assistance  linked  to  this.   ⎯ There  is  a  failure  to  comply  with  State  regulations  regarding  financial  compensation  to  victims.                                                                                                                 15  Protocol  to  Prevent,  Suppress  and  Punish  Trafficking  in  Persons,  especially  Women  and  Children),  ratified  in  Palermo  in  2000.   United  Nations  Convention  against  Transnational  Organised  Crime.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     49       ⎯ Legal  proceedings  do  not  sufficiently  guarantee  the  protection  of  witnesses  and/or  do  not  end  in   firm  convictions.   ⎯ There  are  difficulties  in  international  coordination  and  lack  of  protection  for  the  families  of  the   women  who  remain  in  the  country  of  origin.   ⎯ In   some   cases,   victims   state   the  wish   to   continue   paying   off   their   debts   to   those   that   exploit   them  in  order  to  prevent  threats  from  being  carried  out.       Procedure  for  action     Detection   The  SAS  performs  important  work  in  identifying  women  who  are  in  the  potential  situation  of  becoming   victims   of   trafficking   in   human   beings   for   purposes   of   sexual   exploitation   of   women   who   are   in   situations  of  exploitation.     Observation   and   direct   interventions   in   the   street   have   revealed   the   need   to   gather,   objectify   and   improve  our  approach  to  the  phenomenon  of  trafficking  in  persons.  To  this  end,  the  service  has  drawn   up   a   list   of   indicators   to   help   identify   situations   of   people   trafficking   with   purpose   of   sexual   exploitation16   aimed   at   improving   the   detection   in   the   open   environment,   complemented   by   contact   and   continued   socio-­‐educational   intervention   with   the   women   on   the   part   of   educators   and   health   workers.  Finally,   interdisciplinary  teamwork   is   implemented,  action  that   involves  cooperation  between   the  service  director,  the  social  worker  and  the  psychologist.     Approach   It  should  be  noted  that  the  profile  and  personal  and  social  situations  of  the  victims  vary  greatly,  and  the   form  of  approach  should  therefore  be  considered  case  by  case,  on  an  individual  basis.   In  all  cases  coordination  is  maintained  with  the  City  Police  and  the  Catalan  Police  Central  Unit  on  Human   Trafficking,   informing  them  about  the  situation  and  establishing  the  most  appropriate  mechanisms  for   collaboration  and  action:17     • When  the  woman  is  identified  in  the  street  and  explicitly  requests  protection  as  the  victim  of  human   trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation:   ⎯ She  is  referred  to  emergency  assistance  provisions  through  educational  accompaniment   by   SAS  workers   and/or,   outside   the   operational   hours   of   the   SAS,   the   intervention   of   CUESB,  the  Barcelona  Centre  for  Social  Emergencies.     • When   the   woman   is   identified   in   the   street   by   SAS   workers   but   does   not   explicitly   request   protection:   ⎯ an  educational  and  accompaniment  process   jointly  agreed  with   the  woman   is  put   into   practice:  she  is  helped  in  decision  making  and  in  the  process  of  self-­‐identification  as  the   victim   of   a   crime;   she   is   given   guidance   in   breaking   her   links   with   the   network   or   individual   that   is   exploiting  her;  work   is   aimed  at   gradually  helping  her   to  move  away   from   her   habitual   environment;   she   is   offered   support   and   accompaniment   in   finding                                                                                                                 16Sources  used   to  define   indicators:  Guía  para   la   identificación  de   la  Trata  de   la  Red  Española  contra   la  Trata;  World  Health   Organisation  recommendations;  UNODC  indicators.   17  GUB-­‐ABITS  coordination  protocol.  Instruction  no.  11/13.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     50       housing  and  covering  her  basic  needs  and  on  procedures  for  obtaining  documentation;   etc.   ⎯ If   necessary,   and   the   woman   wishes   to   report   a   crime,   the   SAS   legal   representation   service   to   assist   victims   of   human   trafficking   for   the   purposes   of   sexual   exploitation   enters  into  operation.   ⎯ If  necessary,  the  woman  is  referred  to  emergency  shelter  provisions.   ⎯ She   is  accompanied   to   the  National  Police   to   formally   request   the  period  of   reflection   established  by  law.   ⎯ If   the   woman   requests   voluntary   return   to   her   country   of   origin,   coordination   is   established  with  the  International  Organisation  for  Migration  (IOM).   ⎯ Coordination   is   maintained   with   the   Agency’s   different   services   for   integration   into   training   and   employment   integration   in   order   to   accompany   the  woman   in   the   social   and  employment  integration  process.       ü Most  of  the  women  provided  with  assistance  by  the  SAS  are  potential  victims  of  human  trafficking   for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation.   ü Four  women  were  attended  by  the  legal  representation  service  (those  that  finally  decided  to  make   an  official  report  as  victims).   ü In  2013,  two  women  began  legal  proceedings  with  the  guidance  of  SAS  service  workers.       6.2  Comprehensive  assistance  for  women  involved  in  prostitution  and  women   who  are  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       Assistance  for  women  who  are  victims  of  human  trafficking   for   the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  has   been   provided   through   a   specific   programme   since   2006.   The   specialisation   of   this   resource   and   the   differences   in  profile  compared  to  women  who  are  victims  of  domestic  violence   led  to  the  decision  to   establish  this  cooperation  agreement,  which  has  since  been  renewed.       The  programme  organises  direct  residential  intervention  in  three  stages:  emergency  stage;  permanence   stage;  and  autonomous  stage.     Emergency  stage     Barcelona  City  Council  subsidises  the  emergency  stage  directly  through  the  offices  of  the  ABITS  Agency.   The  overall  goal  of  this  process  is  to  provide  women  who  have  been  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the   purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  and/or  immersed  in  an  environment  of  prostitution  with  safe  shelter  and   to  accompany  them  in  their  process  of  personal  recovery.  The  route  for  access  to  this  service  is  through   a  process  of  contact  in  which  an  initial  interview  is  conducted  in  order  to  assess  the  woman’s  requests,   always  taking  into  account  whether  or  not  the  situation  is  one  of  emergency.     In  2013,  a  total  of  15  women  were  provided  with  assistance  at  this  emergency  stage,  14  of  them  for  the   first  time,  and  one  who  had  already  received  assistance  in  2012.     Of  these  15  women:     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     51       -­‐ Two   entered   the   programme   for   voluntary   return   to   their   country   of   origin   through   the   International  Organisation  for  Migration  (IOM)18  (four  women  in  2012),  in  coordination  with  the   Civil  Guard,  who  accompanied  them  to  the  airport  departure  gate.   -­‐ Two  left  to  live  independently.   -­‐ Two  continued  in  the  emergency  stage  at  31  December  2013.   -­‐ Six  continued  to  the  permanence  stage.   -­‐ One  was  referred  to  another  resource  for  reasons  of  security.   -­‐ Two  did  not  achieve  the  goals  agreed  with  the  team  and  dropped  out  of  the  service.     87%  of   the  women  given  emergency  assistance  continued   to  work   towards   the  goals  agreed  with   the   team.  The  average  stay  in  emergency  shelter  was  21  days.       Of  the  total  of  15  women,  60%  were  referred  as  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual   exploitation  in  the  city  of  Barcelona,  13.33%  were  exploited  outside  Catalonia  with  Barcelona  as  the  final   destination,  13.33%  were  identified  by  security  forces  before  exploitation  took  place  and  the  remaining   13.33%  were  referred  from  other  cities.       60%  of  the  women  were  referred  by  security  forces  (44%  in  2012),  13.33%  by  the  ABITS  Agency’s  Socio-­‐ Educational   Assistance   Service   (SAS)   (25%   in   2012),   20%   by   NGOs   (19%   in   2012)   and   the   remaining   6.67%  were  referred  by  Sisters  of  Adoration.     The  profile  of  the  women  provided  with  assistance  continued  to  wholly  comprise  migrant  women:     ORIGIN  OF  WOMEN   PROVIDED  WITH   ASSISTANCE   2012   %   2012   Number  of   women   2013   %   2013   Number  of   women   Africa   56.25   9   40   6   Nigeria     7     5   Senegal     1     -­‐   Morocco     1     -­‐   Republic   of   the  Congo     -­‐     1   Eastern  Europe   43.75   7   46.67   7   Romania     3     1   Bulgaria*     3     1   Russia     1     1   Armenia-­‐ Russia     -­‐     1   Poland     -­‐     1   Albania     -­‐     1   Hungary     -­‐     1   China   -­‐   -­‐   13.33   2   TOTAL   100.00   16   100.00   15*   *One  of  the  women  holds  dual  nationality.                                                                                                                   18  All  voluntary  returns  (through  the  IOM)  were  to  Eastern  European  countries.     State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     52                         With  regard  to  the  women’s  administrative  situation  at  the  time  they  began  to  receive  assistance  from   this   service,   60%  possessed  documentation   (62%   in  2012),   33%  were  without  documentation   (25%   in   2012)  and  the  remaining  7%  were  women  whose  documents  had  been  retained  by  the  police   (13%   in   2012).  Of  the  women  with  documents,  only  three  were  in  a  regularised  administrative  situation.     In  order  to  promote  their  physical  and  psychological  wellbeing,  the  women  are  provided  with  access  to   healthcare.  Thus,  of   the  15  women  assisted   in   the  emergency  stage,  10   received  medical   care,  with  a   total   of   15   accompaniments   to   medical   appointments   (gynaecology,   general   practitioners   and   psychological   assistance),   involving   a   total   of   22   procedures.   One   of   the   women   assisted   received   emergency  treatment  at  EXIL  due  to  her  personal  and  emotional  state,  with  rapid  response  appropriate   to  her  needs.     In  2013,  21  women  were  accompanied  to  receive  health  treatment.     Permanence  stage     The  permanence  process  entails  providing  women  with  comprehensive  assistance  and  enabling  them  to   live   together  peacefully,  making  a  physical   and  emotional   recovery   and  developing   their   skills   so   that   they   can   become   socially   integrated   and   self-­‐reliant.   In   2013,   fourteen   women  were   assisted   at   this   stage,  six  of  them  new  users  that  year  and  eight  from  previous  years.     Autonomous  stage  (independent  apartments)     In  2013,  two  apartments  were  maintained  for  the  autonomous  stage,  leased  by  Barcelona  City  Council   and  managed  by  the  organitsation.  Towards  the  end  of  2013,  another  apartment  was  acquired.  through   the   Consortium  of   Social   Services,  which   has  managed   facilities   funded   entirely   by   the  Directorate   of   Women’s  Affairs  since  2009.  The  overall  goal  at  this  stage  is  to  consolidate  the  process  of  empowerment   that  the  women  have  begun.  This   is  the  point   in  the   itinerary  when  the  user  requires  a   less  protected   space   that   provides   a   suitable   setting   for   completing   their   process.   Educational   accompaniment   is   transformed  into  monitoring  and  support.      in  2013,  eleven  women  and  one  minor  received  shelter  in  the  two  apartments:   -­‐  Five  women  entered  the  sheltered  accommodation  for  the  first  time  in  2013.   -­‐  Five  women  and  one  minor  completed  their  autonomy  processes  in  this  accommodation  over   the  course  of  the  year.     -­‐  One  woman  was  expelled  for  breaking  the  rules.     The  sociodemographic  profiles  are  as  follows:   -­‐  Nationality:  seven  women  from  Africa  (six  from  Nigeria  and  one  from  Senegal)  and  four  from   Eastern  European  countries  (three  from  Russia  and  one  from  Romania).   -­‐  The  largest  age  group  was  from  18  to  25  years,  followed  by  the  over  30s.   -­‐  Three  women  had  children  in  their  charge  (one  in  the  country  of  origin).   AGE  GROUPS   2012  %   2013   %   2013   Number   of   women   18-­‐25  years   74   66.67   10   26-­‐30  years   13   13.33   2   Over  30  years     13   20   3   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     53       To  provide  assistance  for  women  who  are  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual   exploitation,  Barcelona  City  Council  implements  this  programme  through  a  cooperation  agreement  with   the  Institute  of  the  Sisters  of  Adoration,  Slaves  of  the  Blessed  Sacrament  and  of  Charity,  Community  of   Sants,  to  promote  the  SICAR  cat  project.     6.3.  RAI  Intervention  for  the  recovery,  empowerment  and  integration  into   employment  of  women  who  have  been  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the   purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     The   RAI   programme   is   aimed   at   women   victims   of   human   trafficking   for   the   purpose   of   sexual   exploitation  with  the  purpose  of  providing  tools  to  integrate  them  into  employment  once  they  leave  the   shelter   accommodation.   The   programme   makes   a   comprehensive   approach   to   questions   of   health,   leisure,   training,   relations   and   employment.   The   process   is   also   complemented   by   the   possibility   of   undergoing   therapy   and   a   process   of   psychological   recovery   (conducted   by   an   organisation   that   specialises  in  providing  assistant  for  migrant  people).19     This   is  a  completely   innovative  programme  for  which  no  references  regarding  any  similar   initiatives   in   Spain   are   known.   A   pilot   scheme   was   set   up   in   the   framework   of   funding   provided   under   the   new   government  measure.       The  RAI  programme  RAI  was   launched  on  1  March  2012  and   closed  on  28   February  2013.   Its   success   prompted  the  establishment  of  a  second  edition,  which  began  in  April  2013  and  will  end  in  March  2014.   This  report  contains  the  figures  on  the  second  programme.     In  2014,  the  programme  will  be  launched  once  more,  with  certain  changes  and  improvements,  enabling   the  women  to  continue  the  process  once  they  have  begun  more  independent  lives.     Sociodemographic  profile     In   this   edition   of   the   RAI   programme,   in   which   18   women   took   part   (data   from   April   2013   to   31   December   2013   are   included),   61%  of   the   participants  were  women   aged   below   25   years,   33%  were   between  25  and  35  years  of  age  and  6%  between  36  and  45  years.       33%   of   the   women   participating   had   studies   lower   than   primary   education,   22%   had   completed   secondary  education,  6%  higher  studies  and  17%  university  studies.     COUNTRIES  OF   ORIGIN   WOMEN   %   Nigeria   11   61.11   Republic  of  the   Congo   1   5.55   Senegal   1   5.55   Albania   1   5.55   Romania   2   11.11   Ukraine   1   5.55   Argentina   1   5.55                                                                                                                 19  Exil.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     54       Of   the   eighteen   women,   three   had   children   and   none   was   living   with   them.   One   had   financial   responsibilities  towards  their  child.  The  children  of  two  women  were   in  care.  However,  all  the  women   said  that  they  had  financial  responsibilities  to  their  families  in  their  countries  of  origin.     Of  all  the  women,  nine  received  individual  psychological  assistance  at  the  Exil  organisation  and  one  was   referred   to  CAS   social   assistance   centres   to   receive   individual   treatment   for   the   consumption  of   toxic   substances   and   to   receive   psychological   assistance.   Moreover,   seven   women   received   assistance   for   healthcare  issues  (gynaecological,  ophthalmic  and  dental,  amongst  others)  and  three  took  part  in  group   art  therapy  sessions.     A  characteristic  of  women  who  are  victims  of  human  trafficking   is  a   lack  of  documentation,  a  problem   that  makes   it  difficult   to  obtain  residence  and  work  permits   in  cases  of  cooperation  with  the  police   in   accordance   with   Article   59.2   of   Spanish   Immigrant   Law.   39%   of   the   women   who   took   part   in   the   programme   had   residence   and   work   permits,   17%   only   residence   permits   and   44%   had   neither   residence  nor  work  permits  (in  the  case  of  the  pre-­‐employment  group,  this  figure  reached  63%).       Those   women   that   underwent   legal   processes,   which   can   often   be   long-­‐drawn   out   in   time,   relived   painful   situations   and   experiences   that,   in   some   cases,   had   repercussions   on   their   state   and   their   participation  in  the  programme.     As  regards  income  other  than  from  employment,  90%  of  the  women  received  no  benefits,  5%  received   non-­‐contributory   benefits   and   the   remaining   5%   received   support   in   applying   for   non-­‐contributory   active  integration  income  (RAI)  that  would  help  them  to  cover  the  basic  costs  of  housing  and  food.  The   fact  that  many  women  have  no  documentation,  which  makes  access  to  benefits  more  difficult  for  them   and,   in   cases  where   they   are  not   linked   to   a   residential   resource,   they  have   even  more  difficulties   in   covering   their   basic   needs   and,   therefore,   sustaining   their   process.   For   this   reason,   in   2014,   the   RAI   programme  will  include  certain  changes  and  improvements  to  cover  the  basic  needs  of  these  women  so   that  they  can  sustain  their  processes  once  they  are  living  more  independently.     Of  the  18  women,  13  lived  in  the  shelter  accommodation  provided  and  the  other  5  lived  independently,   in  shared  apartments.  Three  women  received  financial  aid  for  food,  rent  and  a  training  course.     Regarding   previous   employment   experience,   33%   of   the   women   in   both   groups   had   had   work   experience   in   their   countries  of  origin,  22%  had  no  experience  and   just  17%  had  had  an  employment   contract.     Eighteen  women  were  selected  for  the  RAI  programme  (which  began  in  April  2013  and  will  end  in  March   2014).   Of   these,   fourteen   were   new   incorporations   to   the   programme   and   four   were   continuing   participants  from  the  previous  edition.       Pre-­‐employment  group     The   pre-­‐employment   group  was   formed   by   eight   women,   seven   of   them   referred   by   SICAR   and   one   identified   in  the  selection  process  for  a  social  and  employment   integration  programme20   implemented   in  cooperation  with  the  SAS.  The  group  is  formed  by  women  who  show  themselves  to  be  motivated  to   start   a   process   of   integration   into   the   host   country   and   the   employment  market.   Despite   this   initial   motivation,  the  process  with  this  group  of  women  was  aimed  at  achieving  recovery  and  empowerment   through  a  focus  on  different  spheres  of  life:  relationships,  health,   leisure,  the  host  country  culture  and   basic  and  technical  skills  (knowledge  of  the  Spanish  language  and  computer  use).                                                                                                                   20  In  the  selection  process  for  a  programme  operated  by  Barcelona  City  Council  in  cooperation  with  the  Surt  Foundation.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     55       88%  of  the  women  taking  part  were  under  25  years  and  12%  between  25  and  35  years  of  age.  50%  of   the  women   had   studies   lower   than   primary,   38%   had   completed   primary   studies   and   12%   university   studies.  75%  of  the  women  were  from  Nigeria,  12.5%  from  the  Democratic  Republic  of  the  Congo  and   12.5%  from  Romania.  88%  of  the  women  had  no  children,  13%  one  child.       Employment  group     This  group  was   formed  by  10  women,  all   referred  by  SICAR,   four   from  the  previous  edition  of   the  RAI   programme  that,   for  different  reasons,  had  not  been  able  to  achieve   integration   into  the  employment   market  but  had  shown  interest  and  motivation  in  continuing.       40%  of   the  women   in   this   group  were   aged  below  25   years,   50%  between  25   and  35   years   and   10%   between   36   and   46   years.   20%   of   the   women   had   studies   lower   than   primary,   10%   had   completed   primary   studies,   40%   secondary   studies,   10%   higher   studies   and   20%   university   studies.   50%   of   the   women  were  from  Nigeria  and  10%  from  Senegal,  Romania,  Albania,  the  Ukraine  and  Argentina.  80%  of   the  women  had  no  children  at  the  time  of  entering  the  RAI  programme  and  20%  had  one  child.     The  women  who  had  no  documentation  when  beginning  the  process  gradually  obtained  documents,  as   the  application  processes  were  well  advanced  by  that  time.       Description  of  the  professional  life  project       In  order  to  establish  a  diagnosis  of  the  women’s  needs,  they  were  given  personal  assessment  interviews   at   the   start   of   the   programme   and   throughout   the   process.   They   were   also   accompanied   to   and   coordinated  with  social  services  and  other  organisations  in  order  to  cover  their  basic  needs.       Only  the  women  in  the  pre-­‐employment  group  participated  in  the  module  for  the  development  of  basic   life  skills.  In  it,  they  took  part  in  group  activities  designed  to  integrate  them  into  the  host  country.  There   were  group  actions  to  define   life  challenges  (leisure,  work,  health,  relationships  and  training)   in  which   the   participants   were,   in   the   main,   women   from   the   pre-­‐employment   group.   In   all   cases,   activities   revolved   around   the   subject   of   employment.   The   employment   group   also   took   part   in   individual   approaches  to  the  different  spheres  according  to  the  specific  needs  of  each  woman.  Transversal  sessions   were  also  organised  between  the  two  groups,  focusing  mainly  on  the  sphere  of  relationships.  We  should   not  that,  thanks  to  the  actions  organised,  four  of  the  eighteen  women  who  took  part  were  identified  as   victims  of  abuse  by  their  partners.     GROUP  ACTIONS:  SPHERE   NUMBER  OF  ACTIONS   NUMBER  OF   PARTICIPANTS   Health   7   5   Leisure   7   10   Relationships   5   6   Employment   2   5   TOTAL   4   26       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     56       Implementation  of  projects  defined     The  work  in  this  module  was  aimed  at  developing  the  transversal  skills  necessary  to  achieve  integration   into   employment   through   experiential   group   dynamics,   graphic  material   and   dynamics   for   reflection.   More   specifically,   the   activities   focused   on   skills   where   women   encountered   more   difficulties:   relationship   skills   (teamwork,   interpersonal   relations   and   communication)   and   coping   (responsibility,   negotiation,  adaptability,  organisation).                                               There   were   17   tutorials   to   define   work   plans,   six   on   coordination   with   training   centres   and   15   on   coordination  with  other  organisations.     61%  of  the  women  identified  areas  in  which  they  could  improve  their   lives,  61%  defined  improvement   goals   and   57%   implemented   improvement   processes   of   some   kind.   44%   of   the   women   took   part   in   group  sessions   in  the  module  on   life  skills  and  57%  put  actions   in  their   life  plans  (linked  to  developing   basic  life  skills)  into  practice.                                                                                                                 21  The  study  groups  focused  on  issues  concerning  discrimination,  gender  roles  and  relations  of  trust  and  friendship.   ACTIONS   NUMBER    OF  ACTIONS   NUMBER     OF  WOMEN   Study  groups21   4   11   Balance  of  skills   7   4   Job  search  techniques  and  ICT  skills     6   11   Life  skills  module   9   11   Module  to  develop  transversal  skills     8   7   TUTORIALS   NUMBER    OF  WOMEN   Tutorials  to  monitor  (implementation)  of  work  plans   12   Tutorials  on  retaining  employment     7   Tutorials  for  monitoring  and  maintaining  training   6   Tutorials  to  define  the  work  plan   17   Coordination  with  training  centres     6   Coordination  tutorials   15   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     57       Integration  into  training     Regarding  the  development  of  technical  and  transversal  skills   linked  to  the  employment  market,  there   were  20  cases  of  integration  into  training.           Of  the  30  cases  of  integration  into  training,  20  involved  members  of  the  pre-­‐employment  group  and  10   members   of   the   employment   group.   Most   of   the   cases   of   integration   into   training   in   the   pre-­‐ employment  group  were   for   language   training.   In   the  employment  group,  18%  of  cases  of   integration   into  training  took  the  form  of  work  practice  at  companies.     Integration  into  employment     Six  women  were   integrated   into   the   formal  employment  market   through   fifteen   contracts.  Mediation   with   companies   resulted   in   ten   contracts,   awarded   to   four   women.   As   regards   individual   accompaniment   for   women   actively   seeking   work,   this   resulted   in   five   contracts,   awarded   to   two   women.   In   total,   33%   of   the  women  who   took   part   in   the   RAI   programme   achieved   integration   into   employment  in  the  formal  market.  By  sector,  services  to  companies  accounted  for  53%,  hotels  33%  and   customer  service  13%.  By  type  of  job,  53%  became  integrated  as  cleaning  operations  (eight  cases),  13%   as   chambermaids   (two   cases)   and   13%   as   hostesses   and   promoters   (two   cases).   Moreover,   seven   women  found  work  in  the  informal  employment  market.  It  happens  that  one  single  woman  found  work   both  in  the  formal  and  informal  employment  markets.     By  contract   type,  53%  were  work  or  service  contracts,  27%  temporary  contracts  and  20%  substitution   contracts;   73%   were   full-­‐time,   and   27%   part-­‐time;   67%   were   continuous   timetables,   20%   partial   (mornings),  and  13%  were  on  a  split  timetable  basis.     The  ABITS  Agency  provides  a  line  of  assistance  for  women  who  are  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the   purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  so  that,  after  they  leave  shelter  resources,  they  can  obtain  tools  that  will   enable   them   to   achieve   integration   into   employment.   This   programme   was   implemented   under   a   cooperation   agreement  with   the   Surt   Foundation   and   the   Sisters   of   Adoration,   Slaves   of   the   Blessed   Sacrament  and  of  Charity.       FIELD  OF  INTEGRATION  INTO  TRAINING   Number    of  women   Instrumental  training   1   Language  (Catalan  and  Spanish),  integration  into   training   19   Hairdressing  training  cycle   1   Hostess  training  cycle   1   Vocational  training  in  sewing  and  pattern-­‐making     2   Dental  assistant   2   Programme  for  initial  professional  qualification   (PQPI)   1   Hairdressing  assistant   1   Assistant  waitress   1   Ratification  of  studies  in  country  of  origin     1   TOTAL  INTEGRATION  INTO  TRAINING   30   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     58       6.4.  Other  resources  for  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual   exploitation       Once   more   in   2013,   the   possibility   was   considered   of   providing   assistance   for   victims   of   human   trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  at  the  Municipal  Emergency  Reception  Centre  for  Male   Violence  (CMAU-­‐VM)  in  those  cases  where  referral  to  SICAR  or  shelters  was  not  considered  appropriate   outside   the  working  hours  of   the  Socio-­‐Educational  Assistance  Service.  This  possibility   is   formalised   in   the  protocol  established  by  the  Centre  for  Social  Emergencies  (CUESB).           In   2013,   a   legal   representation   service   was   maintained   for   women   considering   the   possibility   of   reporting  this  crime.  Four  women  were  provided  with  such  assistance,  and  a  training  day  was  organised   for  SAS  service  workers.           State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     59       7.  Networking  and  cooperation       7.1.  ABITS  Plan  Technical  Committee     Over   the   course   of   2013,   the   Technical   Committee   continued   its   work   in   cooperation   with   the   organisations  and  municipal  departments  linked  to  the  Agency:     Organisations     -­‐ Sisters  of  Adoration,  Slaves  of  the  Blessed  Sacrament  and  of  Charity,  SICAR  cat  project     -­‐ Anem  per  feina   -­‐ APIP  Association  for  Promotion  and  Integration  into  Employment     -­‐ Red  Cross,  Barcelona  Local  Assembly.  Health  Division   -­‐ Àmbit  Foundation,  Àmbit  Dona       -­‐ Genera   -­‐ Doctors  of  the  World   -­‐ Oblates  of  the  Holy  Redeemer,  El  Lloc  de  la  Dona   -­‐ Surt.  Women’s  Foundation.  Private  Foundation.     Barcelona  City  Council       -­‐ Director  of  the  Department  of  Equality  and  Health  Services     -­‐ Director  of  the  Women’s  Programme     -­‐ Officer  from  the  ABITS  Agency       -­‐ Director  and  officers  from  SAS         -­‐ Team  of  officers  at  Women’s  Information  and  Assistance  Points  (PIAD)           -­‐ Director  of  the  Office  for  Non-­‐Discrimination  (OND)     -­‐ Officer  from  the  Department  of  Prevention,  Safety  and  Mobility   -­‐ Prevention  officers  from  Ciutat  Vella,  Sant  Martí,  Eixample,  Les  Corts  and  Sants-­‐Montjuïc   districts     -­‐ Consortium  of  Social  Services       Over  the  period,  a  total  of  seven  sessions  took  place,  two  of  them  extraordinary,  called  to  focus  on   specific  single  issues.          7.2.  Other  areas  of  action       Barcelona  City  Council     ⎯ Coordination  with  the  Conflict  Management  Service  of  the  Department  for  Social  Intervention  in   the  Public  Space  (Quality  of  Life,  Equality  and  Sport).   ⎯ Territorial   coordination   work,   in   cooperation   with   district   authorities   in   habitual   liaison   and   participation  in  work  spaces.  In  2012,  when  direct  intervention  began  in  the  Zona  Franca  district,   the  Agency   joined  the  Public  Space  Committee   in  Sants-­‐Montjuïc  district.   In   the  case  of  Ciutat   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     60       Vella,  work  continues  on  the  action  plan  for  the  Plaça  Salvador  Seguí  area  and  the  service  took   part  in  meetings  with  residents,  amongst  other  activities.     ⎯ Liaison  continues  with  the  city  police  with  regard  to  prostitution  in  the  street  and  the  detection   of  situations  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation.  Work  also  continues  on   awareness-­‐raising   actions   for   the   officers  who   take   part   in   police   operations,   informing   them   about   the   Agency’s   resources   and   services   and   about   situations   of   human   trafficking   for   the   purpose  of  sexual  exploitation.   ⎯ Liaison   meetings   were   held   with   Barcelona   City   Council   Legal   Department   (Office   for   Legal   Services).   ⎯ The   Agency   also   continues   to   form   part   of   the   Barcelona   Circuit   city   technical   commission   against   violence   towards   women,   whose   joint   leaders   are   the   Office   for   the   Women’s   Programme  and  Barcelona  Health  Consortium,  and  the  2012  ABITS  report  was  presented  to  this   body.   The   Agency   also   continues   to   provide   information   about   its   resources   and   services   in   some  district  territorial  circuits.         Other  institutions   :   ⎯ Participation   in   areas   for   institutional   relations   provided   for   in   the   government   measure:   delegate   attorney   on   Immigration   Affairs,   and   the   State   Police   Central   Unit   on   Illegal   Immigration  Networks  and  False  Documents  (UCRIF).   ⎯ Technical  liaison  meetings  have  been  held  with  UCRIF,  the  Catalan  Police,  etc.   ⎯ Regarding  awareness-­‐raising,  all  students  requesting   information  about  the  Agency’s  work  and   the   situation   of   women   were   attended.   The   Agency   took   part   in   a   round   table   on   human   trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation  at  a  secondary  school  and  at  vocational  training   centres.     ⎯ Requests   for   information   about   prostitution   and   sexual   exploitation   were   attended   to   from   academics  in  Norway,  Chile,  Portugal  and  the  United  States.     ⎯ The  Association  of  Women   Journalists   of   Catalonia  was   commissioned   to   draft   a   study  of   the   treatment   and   approach   to   prostitution   and   human   trafficking   for   the   purpose   of   sexual   exploitation  in  the  written  press  and  digital  media  with  a  view  to  drawing  up  recommendations   for   distribution.   These   recommendations   were   drafted   in   cooperation   with   journalists   from   several  newspapers  and  institutional  press  offices.   ⎯ Barcelona  City  Council  signed  the  Protocol  on  the  Protection  of  Victims  of  Human  Trafficking  in   Catalonia  along  with  several  Catalan  Government  ministries,   the  State  Government  Delegation   in  Catalonia,  the  Public  Prosecutor’s  Office  in  Catalonia,  the  College  of  Lawyers  of  Catalonia,  the   Official  College  of  Psychologists  of  Catalonia,   the  Catalan  Association  of  Municipalities  and  the   Catalan  Federation  of  Municipalities.   ⎯ The  purpose  of  this  protocol  is  to  adapt  the  Protocol  of  Palermo  the  State  Framework  Protocol   on  human  trafficking  for  the  purposes  of  exploitation  to  Catalonia,  placing  special  emphasis  on   prevention  and  joining  forces  to  identify  victims,  assess  the  risks  to  which  they  are  exposed  and   to  detect   their  needs.  The  protocol  provides   for  particular  care   in  cases  where   the  victims  are   minors,  foreigners  in  irregular  administrative  situations  or  when  they  are  in  any  other  situation   that  makes  them  especially  vulnerable  in  order  to  provide  them  with  comprehensive  protection   and  assistance  that  prevents  secondary  victimisation  and  helps  to  enable  them  to  cooperate  in   legal  processes.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     61       7.3.  Knowledge  acquired  through  networking.  Considerations  on  the   sociodemographic  profile  of  women  engaged  in  prostitution  in  the  city  of   Barcelona     This  report  seeks  to  form  a  picture  of  the  context  and  profile  of  the  majority  of  women  who  are  engaged   in  prostitution  in  the  city  of  Barcelona.  This  study  is  based  on  observation  and  intervention  by  the  ABITS   Agency   and   all   the   work   of   networking,   coordination   and   cooperation   with   other   organisations   and   stakeholders   involved   in  dealing  with  this  phenomenon,  taking   into  account  personal  aspects,  place  of   origin  and  or/social  background.     Although  it  is  not  possible  to  establish  criteria  of  a  general  nature,  there  do  exist  converging  factors  that   help   define   the   circumstances   of   these   women’s   lives   and   enable   advances   to   be   made   towards   improving  the  assistance  provided,  as  well  as  in  the  design  of  new  procedures  and  protocols  for  action.     A  large  number  of  women  of  Nigerian  origin  are  from  the  area  in  and  around  Benin  City.  Most  arrive  in   Barcelona  after  an  extremely  hard  journey  taking  one  or  two  years,  brought  here  by  people  trafficking   networks  that  house  them  in  apartments  in  Morocco  to  wait  for  the  right  time  to  cross  to  the  Peninsula,   usually   on   illegal   boats.   To   ensure   payment   of   the   cost   of   travel   (40,000   euros,   approximately),   the   mafias  coerce  the  women  by  threatening  to  families  they  left  in  Nigeria  and  with  voodoo  rituals.  Some   of   these   threats   are   actually   carried   out,   causing   great   fear   amongst   the   women   and   generating   enormous  pressure  on  them  to  repay  their  debts  by  engaging  in  forced  prostitution.  The  women  tend  to   normalise   this   situation,   which   has   operated   as   a   form   of   migration   over   the   last   15   years.   For   this   reason,  many  of  them  do  not  see  their  situation  as  a  crime  but  as  a  life  choice  made  in  order  to  live  and   survive.  Moreover,  there  is  also  an  additional  feeling  of  loyalty  towards  the  compatriots,  both  male  and   female,  that  they  meet  during  the  course  of  this  process.  All  this  means  that  few  report  their  situation  of   exploitation  to  the  police.  The  areas  where  women  of  Nigerian  origin  engage  in  prostitution  are,  in  the   main,  Les  Corts,  Ciutat  Vella  and  Sant  Martí  (Glòries)  districts.     Women  of  Romanian  origin  engaged  in  prostitution  in  Barcelona  operate  mainly  in  Ciutat  Vella  district   and,  in  smaller  numbers,  Les  Corts.  Most  come  from  areas  in  and  around  Constanta  and  Alexandria,  an   underdeveloped   rural   region   with   harsh   weather   conditions.   Generally   speaking,   we   can   define   two   different   groups   of   women   with   different   circumstances.   In   the   first   group   are   women   that   may   be   victims  of  sexual  exploitation  by  a  member  of  their  own  family  over  a  period  of  years.  During  this  time,   the  women  send  the  money  they  obtain  to  their   families   living   in  Romania  to  their  cover  basic  needs.   According  to  the  dynamic  established,  after  a  time  the  woman  returns  to  Romania  and  another  woman   from  the   family  occupies  her  place,  engaging   in  prostitution,  and   the   first  women   lives  off   the  money   that  the  second  sends  back.  Most  of  the  women  see  this  process  as  a  family  commitment,  as  their  role   within  the  community,  and  do  not   identify  with  a  situation  of  exploitation.  There   is  a  second  group  of   women   of   Romanian   origin   who  may   be   in   situations   of   human   being   trafficking   for   the   purpose   of   sexual  exploitation  by  organised  gangs.  Whilst  until   only  a   few  years  ago   the  extortion  methods  used   involved  extreme   violence,   a   change   in   the  way   these  networks   operate  has   been  observed   recently.   The  mafia  gangs  are  smaller  and  only  control  two  or  three  women.  Control  now  takes  the  form,  not  of   direct  physical  extortion  against  the  women,  but  more  indirect  methods.  One  common  practice  involves   a  man  tricking  the  woman,  making  her  believe  that  he  has  fallen   in   love  with  her,   in  some  cases  even   making  her  pregnant.  This  child  is  placed  in  the  care  of  the  network  and  the  woman  is  moved  to  other   parts  of  Europe  and  coerced   into  engaging   in   forced  prostitution.  Control  and  threats  against  children   coercive  methods  that  ensure  the  submission  of  the  women  and  reduce  the  risk  of  them  running  away   or  reporting  their  situation  to  the  police  so  as  not  to  jeopardise  the  welfare  of  their  children.     In   the   case   of  women   from  Bulgaria,   the   situation   and  model   are   very   similar   to   those   of   Romanian   origin,   though   it   has   been   observed   that   their   personal   circumstances   are   worse.   Most   present   considerable  problems  in  finding  food  and  taking  care  of  their  health.  Their  sociodemographic  profile  is   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation     62       more   diverse   than   other   groups   because   the   criminal   networks   engaged   in   human   trafficking   for   the   purpose  of   sexual  exploitation   from   this   region  are  better  organised.   Socio-­‐educational   contact   in   the   street  with  these  women  is  more  difficult  because  of  the  control  and  submission  they  are  subjected  to.   Women  of  Bulgarian  origin  engaged  in  prostitution  in  Barcelona  mainly  operate  in  the  Ciutat  Vella  and   Les  Corts  districts.     One  of  the  main  reasons  that  some  women  of  Latin  American  origin  give  for  engaging  in  prostitution  is   to  maintain  their  children,  who  often  have  been  left  in  the  charge  of  the  family  in  the  country  of  origin,   and  the  women  are  responsible  for  sending  enough  money  to  maintain  family  stability.  In  other  cases,   their  children  are   in  Barcelona  and   the  women  need  a  source  of   income  to  cover   family  needs.  Some   women  combine  prostitution  with  another  job  in  order  to  supplement  their  income       It   is   observed   that   the   group  of  women   from  Morocco   engaged   in   prostitution   do   so   on  more   of   an   occasional   basis.   They   are   mainly   found   in   Ciutat   Vella   district.   A   very   common   factor   amongst   this   group   is   that   the   women   have   often   been   victims   of   gender   violence   in   their   own   country   and   use   migration  as  a  means  of  becoming  free.  The  fact  that  they  are  not  able  to  regularise  their  situation  and   have  low  levels  of  education  means  that,  once  in  Spain,  they  begin  to  engage  in  prostitution.  The  client   profile   is  generally  made  up  of  Moroccan  and  Pakistani  boys  of  Moroccan  and  Pakistani   from  shops   in   the  Raval  area.  This  is  an  unusual  form  of  prostitution  as  it  is  not  always  associated  with  the  sexual  act,   but  rather  of  being  together,  making  conversation  and  providing  company.       One  of  the  most  common  characteristics  that  help  to  define  prostitution  by  Spanish  women  is  that  they   engage  in  this  activity  during  specific  periods  of  their  lives,  largely  to  resolve  serious  financial  problems.   Many   of   these   women   share   in   common   the   fact   that   they   are   widows,   who   receive   some   sort   of   benefits  such  as  RMI  minimum  wage  for  integration  and  have  very  low  income.  They  operate  on  Ronda   Sant  Antoni,  around  the  Raval  neighbourhood  and  in  Les  Corts  district.  Some  of  them  recently  returned   to  prostitution  in  order  to  provide  financial  support  for  their  entire  families  (children  and  grandchildren),   in  most   cases  broken   families  affected  by   such   situations  as  drug  addiction  of   family  members,   crime   and  serious  illness.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       63       8.  Economic  distribution          ABITS  Agency  budget   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014   SOCIO-­‐EDUCATIONAL  ASSISTANCE  SERVICE  (SAS)                 211.674,23   241.986,71   287.942,50   317.867,27    317.867,27     FINANCIAL  AID  TO  WOMEN                     11.721,00   16.000,00   18.000,00   18.000,00    20.000,00     TRAINING  AND  INTEGRATION  INTO   EMPLOYMENT               Comprehensive  programme  for  re-­‐employment  (DIR)   224.625,85   232.487,75   260.799,35   368.027,93    318.791,78     Recovery,  empowerment  and  integration  into  employment  of   women  victims  of  sexual  exploitation  (RAI)   ….   ….   88.008,90   99.745,99    110.000,00     Personal  advisory  itinerary  for  integration  into  employment  (ITI)   ….   83.290,00   83.290,00   83.290,00    94.624,25     Comprehensive  intervention  with  transsexual  people  (ACCIÓ)   ….   ….   128.727,22   128.727,22    64.000,00     Employment  and  training  itineraries     40.591,25   40.592,00   48.590,00   48.590,00    40.592,00     Accompaniment  service     ….   ….   40.000,00   40.000,00    40.000,00     Dona  Kolors22   ….   ….       ]    18.000,00     “Dona  Impuls”  (Barcelona  Activa)           61.347,00   50.700,00    ….     SOCIAL  ASSISTANCE  FOR  WOMEN                            Intermediate  emergencies  23   24.838,50   24.838,50   24.838,50   24.838,50    27.447,30     LEGAL  ASSISTANCE  TO  WOMEN                     ….   ….   ….   ….    26,031.43     ASSISTANCE  TO  WOMEN  WHO  ENGAGE  IN  PROSTITUTION  IN  BARS,  CLUBS  AND   APARTMENTS                      Eixample   ….   ….   ….   7,808.14    31,232.54                                                                                                                   22  Dona  Kolors  is  not  constituted  as  an  organisation  and  in  2013  and  2012,  8.000  euros  was  provided  for  the  Women  and  Prostitution  agreement.   23  Intermediate  emergencies:  in  2014,  this  included  parenting  workshops  for  Nigerian  women  users  of  the  SAS.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       64        Les  Corts   ….   ….   ….   10,840.00    24,000.00      Rest  of  the  city   ….   10,000.00   20,000.00   20,000.00    20,000.00     ASSISTANCE  TO  VICTIMS  OF  SEXUAL   EXPLOITATION               Shelter  and  protection   96,197,22   99,564.12   99,564.12   99,564.12    99,564.12     Halfway  house  and  independent  apartment   26,368,91   26,368.91   26,368.91   40,939.17    40,939.17     Legal  representation   ….   14,160.00   12,425.00   12,000.00    18,150.00     STUDIES  AND  EVALUATIONS               Study  of  the  situation  of  prostitution  in  the  city  of  Barcelona   ….   ….   ….   30,000..00    61,914.26     Surt  -­‐  DIR-­‐TS  impact   ….   21,073.84   ….   ….    ….     Monitoring  indicators   ....   ….   12,624.79   ….    ….     Impact  of  the  SICAR  programme  of  recovery  from  sexual   exploitation  (SICAR)   ….   ….   10,736.90   ….    ….     Les  Corts   14,160,00   ….   ….   ….    ….     Comparative  study  of  laws   ….   ….   4,356.00   ….    ….     Recommendations  to  the  media   ….   ….   ….   10,384.50    ….     Legislative  and  social  study       ....   ....   25,000..00     ....   ....   SAS  DATABASE               Creation  and  improvement.  Maintenance   40,635,39   3,917.60   10,000..00   20,000..00    10,000..00     OTHER                    Communication,  networking  and  other   18,460   4,381.87   2,673.83   2,700.00    6,700.00     INTERNATIONAL  COOPERATION       ….   ….   20,000..00   ….    ….      TOTAL         709,272.35   818,661.30   1,279,654.01   1,383,647.70    1,389,854.12       State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       65         9.  Impact  indicators  for  programmes  of  integration  into  employment     2013  PROGRAMMES     Cases  of   integration   2011   Cases  of   integration   201224   Cases  of  integration   201325   Notes   Woman  and  Prostitution.  Social  and   employment  programme  2013   20  women     20  contracts     31  women   32  contracts     17  women     17  contracts        12  women  in  the  informal   market   Participation  in  training  activities:     82  women  in  2011   127  women  in  2012   180  women  in  2013   Enfilant  l’Agulla  (“Threading  the   Needle”)    -­‐   2  women     2  contracts     3  women   3  contracts       4  women  in  the  informal   market   Training:   25  women  in  2012   38  women  in  2013   DIR  Comprehensive  programme  for   the  re-­‐employment  of  women   engaged  in  prostitution   30  women   36  contracts     36  women   50  contracts   37  women   45  contracts       20   women   in   the   informal   market   2012   61   participants,   34   of   whom   continued   to   be   active  31/12  (one  group  ends  in  March,  another   in  July).   2013   79   participants,   39   of   whom   continued   to   be   active  31/12  (one  group  ends  in  March,  another   in  July  2014).   ITI  Personal  advisory  itinerary  for  the   employment  of  women  who  have   engaged  in  prostitution    -­‐   16  women     24  contracts     17  women   27  contracts         8   women   in   the   informal   market   2012   25  participants   2013   23  participants     39  integration  into  training                                                                                                                 24Approval  of  the  new  government  measure,  which  signified  an  increase  in  the  number  of  programmes  targeting  integration  into  employment.   25  It  happens  that  one  woman  found  work  in  both  the  formal  and  informal  employment  markets.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       66       Special  accompaniment  provision  for   integration  into  the  employment   market  and  the  social  fabric  of  people   engaged  in  prostitution  and  seek   employment  alternatives      -­‐   10  women   14  contracts   22  women   33  contracts       12   women   in   the   informal   market   2012   44   women.   This   is   a   programme   for   accompaniment   in   integration   and,   therefore,   women  may   join   from   the   programme   launch   to  the  end  of  the  year     2013   84  women   23  integration  into  training   RAI  Intervention  for  the  recovery,   empowerment  and  integration  into   employment  of  women  who  have   been  victims  of  sexual  exploitation    -­‐   2  women     2  contracts   6  women   15  contracts           7  women  in  the  informal   market   2012   12  participants   2013   18  participants   30  integration  into  training   ACCIÓ  Programme  of  comprehensive   intervention  for  transsexual  people   linked  to  prostitution  milieus  in  the   city  of  Barcelona      -­‐   2  women   2  contracts   7  women26   9  contracts         2012   26   participants   with   training,   integration   and   social  itineraries     2013   31  participants   “Dona  Impuls”  (Promotion  of   Women)    -­‐    -­‐   10  women   10  contracts     1   woman   in   the   informal   market   43  participants     TOTAL  NUMBER  OF  WOMEN   RECEIVING  CONTRACTS   50     99     119 27                                                                                                                     26  Figures  for  the  period  from  1  January  2013  to  31  December  2013,  corresponding  to  two  different  editions  of  the  programme.   27  159  contracts  in  2013,  with  64  women  integrated  into  the  informal  employment  market.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       67       10.  Indicators  of  programmes  to  enter  enclosed  spaces     2013  PROGRAMMES   Enclosed  spaces   visited   2013   Women   contacted   201328   Different   women  given   assistance     201329   Notes   Eixample     30     141   45   Launch  of  pilot  programme  1/10/13.   Les  Corts   1430   60   17   Launch  of  pilot  programme  1/7/13.   Rest  of  the  city   1931   217   162   Launch  of  pilot  programme  24/2/2011.   TOTAL   63   418   224                                                                                                                     28  Due  to  the  nature  of  the  locales,  the  women  are  mobile  and  one  single  woman  may  have  been  contacted  more  than  once.   29  The  women  receive  individual  monitoring  and  assistance.   30  The  intervention  in  Les  Corts  district  enabled  the  team  to  note  that  many  enclosed  spaces  border  on  Sants  district.  Accordingly,  in  2014  the  intervention  will  be  extended  to  this  area.   31  The  programme  was  launched  in  2011.  Although  the  service  visited  19  locales,  women  from  88  enclosed  spaces  were  contacted  and  provided  with  assistance.  Many  of  them  already  knew  about  the   programme  and  approached  it  under  their  own  initiative.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       68       11.  Evaluation  and  conclusions       • The  ABITS  Agency  covers  all  areas  of  the  city  where  prostitution  goes  on  in  the  street.   • In   2013,   the  Agency  participated   in  14  police  operations   (one   at   hairdressers’   establishments   and  beauty   salons   run  by  Chinese  people).   It  has  provided  assistance   two  women,   receiving  a   highly  positive  evaluation,  as  the  service  reached  new  women  and  provided  them  with  social  or   containment  assistance  in  those  moments.  The  Agency  also  assisted  the  police  in  their  work  and   helped  to  raise  mutual  knowledge  and  understanding.     • In  this  report,  the  figures  are  broken  down  by  gender.  In  2013,  6.3%  of  people  attended  were   transsexuals  and  93.7%  women.     • Contacts  made  and  assistance  provided  increased  by  25.24%  and  10.20%  respectively.     • 409  different  women  were  assisted  in  2013.     • 126  of  these  409  women  were  provided  with  assistance  for  the  first  time  in  2013.   • The  requests  received  by  the  team  rose  to  11,122  compared  to  9,069  in  the  previous  year.  This   represents   an   increase   of   22.64%.   Main   requests:   housing   (110.94%),   documentation   procedures  (73.02%),  requests  relating  to  children  (64.48%)  and  social  services  (59.95%).   • There   was   a   28.37%   increase   in   psychological   assistance   interviews.   88.88%   of   the   women   provided  with  assistance  were  or  had  been  victims  of  male  violence.   • 15%  of   accompaniments  were  outside   the   city  of  Barcelona.  A   total   of   647  accompaniments   were  provided.   • Accompaniment  decreased  by  4.44%  (from  677  in  2012  to  647  in  2013)  because:   -­‐ The  Agency  has  worked  constantly  over  the  last  six  years  to  promote  the  autonomy  and   empowerment  of  the  women.   -­‐ The   users’   increased   knowledge   about   the   different   organisations   with   which   the   Agency  establishes  cooperation  agreements  makes  accompaniment  unnecessary.   • The   impossibility   of   Romanian   joining   programmes   for   integration   into   employment.   This   is   because,   although   they   are   European   citizens  with   residence   permits,   Spain’s  moratorium   on   ratifying  international  treaties  means  that  they  cannot  obtain  work  permits.   • There  was  a  26.96%  increase  in  the  number  of  coordination  operations  between  the  SAS  and   other  municipal  services  in  the  city  of  Barcelona  and  municipalities  in  the  metropolitan  area.   • 87%  of  all  women  whose   files  were  open  at   the  end  of   the  year  were  migrants.   The   largest   groups   were   women   from   Sub-­‐Saharan   Africa,   followed   by   those   from   Eastern   European   countries,  Latin  America,  Spain,  Morocco  and,  for  the  first  time,  Asia.  By  country,  the  orders  is  as   follows:   Nigeria   (27.06%),   Romania   (23.42%),   Spain   (12.9%),   Ecuador   (7.50%)   and   Morocco   (1.50%).   • 72.6%  of  women  attended  were  in  a  regular  administrative  situation.     • 92%  had  health  cards.  The  tendency  for  the  number  of  women  with  access  to  health  services  to   rise  since  the  service  was  established  continues.   State  of  implementation  and  impact  of  actions  by  the  ABITS  Agency  in  its  comprehensive  approach  to  prostitution  and  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual  exploitation       69       • Approximately  half  of  the  women  provided  with  assistance  are  mothers.   • The  situation  of  the  Romanian  women  became  complicated  as  they  reside  legally   in  Spain  but   cannot  work   on   the   formal   employment  market.   This   prevents   them   from  being   able   to   take   part  in  training  and  integration  into  employment  processes  despite  the  availability  of  resources   and  the  requests  these  women  themselves  put  forward.   • Consolidation   of   the   RAI   programme   for   the   recovery,   empowerment   and   integration   into   employment  of  women  who  have  been  victims  of  human  trafficking  for  the  purpose  of  sexual   exploitation,  in  which  18  women  took  part.  This  is  a  completely  innovative  programme,  and  no   similar  initiatives  are  known  in  Spain.       • Consolidation   of   the   Enfilant   l’Agulla   (“Threading   the   Needle”)   programme,   a   social   entrepreneurial   initiative   that   combines   training   in   sewing   (38  women   took   part   in   the   latest   edition)   and   garment-­‐making   in   a   dedicated  workshop.   The   clothes   are   sold   under   the   Dona   Kolors   social   brand.   The   programme   led   to   the   recruitment   of   four   of   the   women   who   completed  the  training  (2012-­‐2013  period)  for  jobs  at  the  workshop.     • 20.20%   increase   in   the   number   of   women   integrated   into   employment   with   contract   compared  to  the  previous  year.   • The  launch  of  two  pilot  programmes  to  enter  and  intervene  in  closed  spaces  in  the  Eixample   and   Les   Corts   districts   enabled   numbers   of   women   identified   and   interventions   in   locales   where  prostitution  takes  place,   increasing  our  understanding  of  the  situation  and  attending  to   the  women’s  needs.         bcn.cat/ dona twitter.com/barcelona_cat facebook.com/BarcelonaDones BCN 2013 report on the state of implementation and impact of actions by the ABITS Agency in its comprehensive approach to prostitution and human trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation 2013 REPORT