Is response to fire influenced by dietary specialization and mobility? A comparative study with multiple animal assemblages

Abstract

This study was partially supported by the ‘‘Conveni de Collaboracio´ per al desenvolupament del Pla de gestio´ integral per a la conservacio´ dels sistemes naturals de la Xarxa de Parcs Naturals’’ signed by Obra Social La Caixa and the Diputacio´ de Barcelona, and by the projects CGL2011-29539 and Consolider Montes CSD2008-00040 granted by the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science (MEC). Xavier Santos is supported by a post-doctoral Grant (SFRH/ BPD/73176/2010) from Fundac¸a˜o para a Cieˆncia e a Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Fire is a major agent involved in landscape transformation and an indirect cause of changes in species composition. Responses to fire may vary greatly depending on life histories and functional traits of species. We have examined the taxonomic and functional responses to fire of eight taxonomic animal groups displaying a gradient of dietary and mobility patterns: Gastropoda, Heteroptera, Formicidae, Coleoptera, Araneae, Orthoptera, Reptilia and Aves. The fieldwork was conducted in a Mediterranean protected area on 3 sites (one unburnt and two burnt with different postfire management practices) with five replicates per site. We collected information from 4606 specimens from 274 animal species. Similarity in species composition and abundance between areas was measured by the Bray-Curtis index and ANOSIM, and comparisons between animal and plant responses by Mantel tests. We analyze whether groups with the highest percentage of omnivorous species, these species being more generalist in their dietary habits, show weak responses to fire (i.e. more similarity between burnt and unburnt areas), and independent responses to changes in vegetation. We also explore how mobility, i.e. dispersal ability, influences responses to fire. Our results demonstrate that differences in species composition and abundance between burnt and unburnt areas differed among groups. We found a tendency towards presenting lower differences between areas for groups with higher percentages of omnivorous species. Moreover, taxa with a higher percentage of omnivorous species had significantly more independent responses of changes in vegetation. High- (e.g. Aves) and low-mobility (e.g. Gastropoda) groups had the strongest responses to fire (higher R scores of the ANOSIM); however, we failed to find a significant general pattern with all the groups according to their mobility. Our results partially support the idea that functional traits underlie the response of organisms to environmental changes caused by fire.

This study was partially supported by the ‘‘Conveni de Collaboracio´ per al desenvolupament del Pla de gestio´ integral per a la conservacio´ dels sistemes naturals de la Xarxa de Parcs Naturals’’ signed by Obra Social La Caixa and the Diputacio´ de Barcelona, and by the projects CGL2011-29539 and Consolider Montes CSD2008-00040 granted by the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science (MEC). Xavier Santos is supported by a post-doctoral Grant (SFRH/ BPD/73176/2010) from Fundac¸a˜o para a Cieˆncia e a Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Fire is a major agent involved in landscape transformation and an indirect cause of changes in species composition. Responses to fire may vary greatly depending on life histories and functional traits of species. We have examined the taxonomic and functional responses to fire of eight taxonomic animal groups displaying a gradient of dietary and mobility patterns: Gastropoda, Heteroptera, Formicidae, Coleoptera, Araneae, Orthoptera, Reptilia and Aves. The fieldwork was conducted in a Mediterranean protected area on 3 sites (one unburnt and two burnt with different postfire management practices) with five replicates per site. We collected information from 4606 specimens from 274 animal species. Similarity in species composition and abundance between areas was measured by the Bray-Curtis index and ANOSIM, and comparisons between animal and plant responses by Mantel tests. We analyze whether groups with the highest percentage of omnivorous species, these species being more generalist in their dietary habits, show weak responses to fire (i.e. more similarity between burnt and unburnt areas), and independent responses to changes in vegetation. We also explore how mobility, i.e. dispersal ability, influences responses to fire. Our results demonstrate that differences in species composition and abundance between burnt and unburnt areas differed among groups. We found a tendency towards presenting lower differences between areas for groups with higher percentages of omnivorous species. Moreover, taxa with a higher percentage of omnivorous species had significantly more independent responses of changes in vegetation. High- (e.g. Aves) and low-mobility (e.g. Gastropoda) groups had the strongest responses to fire (higher R scores of the ANOSIM); however, we failed to find a significant general pattern with all the groups according to their mobility. Our results partially support the idea that functional traits underlie the response of organisms to environmental changes caused by fire.

This study was partially supported by the ‘‘Conveni de Collaboracio´ per al desenvolupament del Pla de gestio´ integral per a la conservacio´ dels sistemes naturals de la Xarxa de Parcs Naturals’’ signed by Obra Social La Caixa and the Diputacio´ de Barcelona, and by the projects CGL2011-29539 and Consolider Montes CSD2008-00040 granted by the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science (MEC). Xavier Santos is supported by a post-doctoral Grant (SFRH/ BPD/73176/2010) from Fundac¸a˜o para a Cieˆncia e a Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Fire is a major agent involved in landscape transformation and an indirect cause of changes in species composition. Responses to fire may vary greatly depending on life histories and functional traits of species. We have examined the taxonomic and functional responses to fire of eight taxonomic animal groups displaying a gradient of dietary and mobility patterns: Gastropoda, Heteroptera, Formicidae, Coleoptera, Araneae, Orthoptera, Reptilia and Aves. The fieldwork was conducted in a Mediterranean protected area on 3 sites (one unburnt and two burnt with different postfire management practices) with five replicates per site. We collected information from 4606 specimens from 274 animal species. Similarity in species composition and abundance between areas was measured by the Bray-Curtis index and ANOSIM, and comparisons between animal and plant responses by Mantel tests. We analyze whether groups with the highest percentage of omnivorous species, these species being more generalist in their dietary habits, show weak responses to fire (i.e. more similarity between burnt and unburnt areas), and independent responses to changes in vegetation. We also explore how mobility, i.e. dispersal ability, influences responses to fire. Our results demonstrate that differences in species composition and abundance between burnt and unburnt areas differed among groups. We found a tendency towards presenting lower differences between areas for groups with higher percentages of omnivorous species. Moreover, taxa with a higher percentage of omnivorous species had significantly more independent responses of changes in vegetation. High- (e.g. Aves) and low-mobility (e.g. Gastropoda) groups had the strongest responses to fire (higher R scores of the ANOSIM); however, we failed to find a significant general pattern with all the groups according to their mobility. Our results partially support the idea that functional traits underlie the response of organisms to environmental changes caused by fire.